Who are my keepers?

[Noob616]

H2H points league, skaters are G, A, PPP, SOG, HIT, PIM, +/-, goalies are SV, W, SO, and -GA. We keep 3 skaters and 1 goalie, looking for some help with choosing. At G I have Price, Darling, and Bernier so that's obviously Price.

At skater I have Kucherov, Crosby, Eichel, Hall, Byfuglien, Boeser, and Sergachev who I'm considering in roughly that order. Kuch is a lock and I'm 99% on Crosby but I'm conflicted between Hall and Eichel. Eichel is probably the better asset in a vacuum but Hall at LW is enticing, especially when I already have Crosby at C and NJD is on the upswing compared to the gong show that is the Sabres. It's an auction draft so there's no draft picks to trade for either.

Up until a couple days ago my choice was easily Kucherov, Crosby, Hall, but one of the top teams in my league dropped Eichel. It sounds insane but it's a money league and he's trying to make a run so he wants another active player (and his keepers are fine - likely Klingberg, Hedman, Monahan). If dropping Eichel for an active player gets him $200 it's hard to criticize too much.

[MZac]

Dropping Eichel is insane. Monahan over eichel? Seriously that is insane with or without injury there had to be a trade market before a drop.

As is I like Kuch, Crosby, Eichel, and Price.

I'd look at approaching the McDavid owner and I'd offer Crosby and Eichel for McDavid and see if he bites. I'd ultimately give any 2 of them for McDavid and then gives you the room to keep Hall. My 2 c.

[Noob616]

Dropping Eichel is insane. Monahan over eichel? Seriously that is insane with or without injury there had to be a trade market before a drop.

As is I like Kuch, Crosby, Eichel, and Price.

I'd look at approaching the McDavid owner and I'd offer Crosby and Eichel for McDavid and see if he bites. I'd ultimately give any 2 of them for McDavid and then gives you the room to keep Hall. My 2 c.

Yeah not exactly sure why he didn't try to trade Eichel but whatever. Yeah I'm gonna try that with McDavid's owner, also thinking about a similar deal for Karlsson. I think I'm fairly likely to get Karlsson since his owner is the most active in the league and I think he'd understand the value of getting two elite keepers back for one keeper and a throw in.

[Noob616]

So apparently it's actually 4 players of which 1 can be a goalie. So I'm almost certainly going to let Price go and keep all 4. It's a 12 team league so since I'm letting Price go at most there will be 11 goalies kept and with such a stacked group of forward keepers I could basically just target G and D in the draft and fill out my F with late picks and/or waiver pickups.