A few scenarios...

[GinFizz]

Please select one of the following deals for my team. Points are as follows in this 14 team dynasty league:

Goals ................................. 1.0 (1.5 for defensemen)
Assist ................................ 1.0
+Power Play Pts ................. 0.5
+Game-Winning Goals ........ 1.0
+Hat-Trick .......................... 1.0
Plus/Minus +/- .................... 0.2
Hits ................................... 0.1
Blocked Shots .................... 0.2
Penalty Minutes ................. -0.2
Fights ................................ 0.5

A. Malkin, Hall and Horvat for Kane, Stamkos and Nurse
B. Malkin, Hall and Girgensons for Kane Stamkos and Nurse
C. Malkin, Hall and Hertl for Kane, Stamkos, Nurse and Nelson
D. Stay put and dont make a move.

All the help is very much appreciated.

[sammynos]

You have Malkin/Hall and looking to acquire Kane/Stamkos or vice versa?

[jmouland]

I prefer the Malkin Hall side in all those deals although C is the closest for me...So assuming you're the Malkin, Hall side I'd pick D.

[GinFizz]

I have Malkin and Hall..

[sammynos]

I would say D only because I don't see a significant enough upgrade in the other scenarios.

[evans334]

I prefer the Malkin Hall side in all those deals although C is the closest for me...So assuming you're the Malkin, Hall side I'd pick D.

I second this, stand pat.

[GinFizz]

I could use a young D man though.. Is Nurse too far away, development wise, to make a difference.?

[Kofax]

I would keep Malkin/Hall. I'd pick C if I absolutely had to make a move.

[Pengwin7]

I love option C for you.

You get Nelson/Nurse and you give up Hertl.
I don't even like Hertl... so this is nice.

I much prefer P.Kane/Stamkos over Hall/Malkin.

[Fighting_Emu]

I could use a young D man though.. Is Nurse too far away, development wise, to make a difference.?

D.

Hes probably awhile away- yes. More importantly hes not worth swapping superstars to acquire. A depth piece? Sure. In this eal I honestly dont care ho the 3r piece is. You nee to decide whose better out of the 4 big names. Its close- but Im going Malkin/Hall.