Jaroslav Halak vs. Sergei Bobrovsky?

[mygambition]

Well now that the islanders just got two serviceable defenseman... unless they are a product of the team?

I'm wondering if this would be insane or worth it to consider dropping Bob for Halak (a tiny cap savings of just over 1.1M).
Yes, I know Bob had a fantastic second half (I'm probably looking to snag him back just before the end of december for that run, but in the short term, particular with Blue Jackets missing their entire second line of RyJo, Horton and Jenner - could this be a decent bet?

Check out my sig for the categories and my team:
I got King Henrik, but last year proved, he can be human sometimes.
Allen is my spot starter in my 3rd string goalie whenever he can.

What do you guys think? Some advice and projections on which goalie might do better in the short term (like next couple of weeks/months until RyJo signs) would be fantastic.

First half projections?

[Kane Ryker]

No. You keep Bobvrosky. Do not drop him for Halak. End of story

[Axeman33]

I'm wondering if this would be insane or worth it to consider dropping Bob for Halak (a tiny cap savings of just over 1.1M).

I'd go with insane if these are my choices.

[lucifer316]

stick with Bob

[mounD]

Bob-Bob-Bob. Bob-bob-ra- Ann.