Malkin + more for Voracek and Bjugstad

[SabresFan76]

Points only.

I have Malkin.
Offer on the table

Malkin + Stolarz + 4th
for
Voracek + Bjustad.

Factor : age, bandaid boy, upside.

Do it or not

[Laendarian]

nope

[junyab]

I would hope you could get more for top 10 forward then Voracek and Bjudstad...and I wouldn't do this if it was the only offer on the table.

[rainydrinkwater]

Not anywhere near enough value for Malkin IMO.

[Dobber]

Points only.

I have Malkin.
Offer on the table

Malkin + Stolarz + 4th
for
Voracek + Bjustad.

Factor : age, bandaid boy, upside.

Do it or not

Factor: you'd have to be on crack

Also, why on earth would age be a factor, what's Malkin like 28? I'll worry about age when he's 38

Even if the other person offered Voracek+Bjugstad+Stolarz+1st+1st+Kitchen Sink you don't do it.

[Go Puck Yourself]

Yea, pretty poor offer. I would reject in a heartbeat

[Magicstew]

Another No vote
Also when you add extra players you usually have to drop someone.

[VincentVega]

Factor: you'd have to be on crack

Also, why on earth would age be a factor, what's Malkin like 28? I'll worry about age when he's 38

Even if the other person offered Voracek+Bjugstad+Stolarz+1st+1st+Kitchen Sink you don't do it.

Maybe if it's a really nice kitchen sink but otherwise I wouldn't do it either.

[ericdaoust]

Points only.

I have Malkin.
Offer on the table

Malkin + Stolarz + 4th
for
Voracek + Bjustad.

Factor : age, bandaid boy, upside.

Do it or not

Is Malkin old? I find it weird that I've had to write this multiple times over the last week.

[Kofax]

Malkin's floor is greater than Voracek and Bjugstad's upside. What a horrible deal.

[Fast Tony DeNiro]

Malkin's floor is greater than Voracek and Bjugstad's upside. What a horrible deal.

Haha seriously. In 60 games Malkin will outscore both of these guys in their best years.

I understand maybe shopping Malkin around if the injuries scare you. I've tested the waters a bit in my league for that reason. But this is just giving him away. Remind people you talk to that he's one of the only two players realistically capable of scoring 110 points in any given season.

[ericdaoust]

Remind people you talk to that he's one of the only two players realistically capable of scoring 110 points in any given season.

To add to this point, it would be worth reminding potential trade partners that only one player topped 87 points last year!

[Canucks_fan18]

[lucifer316]

is it April or something

as for Malkin being old, isn't 3 years younger than old old as well

[pmorrow]

I think its pretty obvious where everyone else is leaning in this thread, but I'll just add that guys like Malkin, Crosby, etc aren't going to be "over the hill" until they hit 35 at the earliest. I would expect him production to be superior to Voracek for at least the next 6 years. And if you're more concerned about how this deal will look in 7 years ahead instead of the 5 or 6 in front of you, you're thinking waaaay too far ahead for fantasy (IMO). People are always looking towards the future in dynasties, but what if the guy youre trading is going to be good for a really long time? Who's to say Voracek doesn't start declining at 30, while Malkin is still ripping it up at 35? I just think the rules of age are less relevant with superstars like Malkin.