Which goalies to keep...

[MHLPrez]

Keeper league allows us to keep 2 goalies. Goalie stats are wins, SV%, Shutouts. Which 2 do I keep from the following:

Gibson
Kuemper
Harding
Howard

My gut says to go with Gibson and Kuemper but they both could be playing in the minors most of the season. I have a good shot at winning this year but would hate to lose a future asset. Any incite would be helpful.

[teepee1]

Gibson and Howard for me. Gibson is a risk, he may well end up back in minors. How many goalies do you play? Who would be available in the draft?

[petegreg21]

Yup, Howard and Gibson

[vitun-tyhmä]

Gibson and Howard

[kekay_20]

Gib and howard

[The Good Sir]

Gibson and Howard for me. Gibson is a risk, he may well end up back in minors. How many goalies do you play? Who would be available in the draft?

Gibson and Howard for me too with the info provided. Also interested however in who would be available for redraft?

[MHLPrez]

12 team league, everyone can keep 2 goalies max.
Most tenders will be gone by then, as I traded my first rounder this past season.
Like I said, I have a good shot at winning this year so not sure if I can afford to take a chance on a goalie they may spend some time in the minors with Gibson.
May be able to steal him back in the draft... but he isn't exactly a secret anymore. We can only start 2 a night.

Any expansion on why you chose howard or Gibson?

[MarmotKing]

Gibson and Howard for me too.

[havanablast21]

Another vote forbhoward with a flier in Gibson. He's worth the wait.

[Scorgasm]

Howard because he will get you the most wins of the bunch (this year). Health with Harding is a RED FLAG! Gibson will be the best of the bunch very soon and he could potentially become #1 this year. I think he is worth sitting on until he becomes #1. Kuemper still has Backstrom and Harding to battle with BUT both are injury prone which could put him number 1. I could see Gibson drafted early if you let him go while the others would probably hang around for a while.

[Fast Tony DeNiro]

Gibson and Howard.

Gibby gives you a high-end goalie for your future. He'll give you some games this season, possibly in a 1A-1B setup. And within the next two years he will be in an all-out battle with Andersen for starts.

Howard is the best choice for this season. Detroit might be on a bit of a decline, but they'll still challenge for a playoff spot and Howard is going to start 60-65 games if healthy. That should come out to 30-35 wins, with serviceable numbers.