Let\'s play: Who would you rather keep?

**jackalope** · March 3, 2009, 10:52 PM

I\'d go with Butler here. More of an all around bat. Still only 21 and playing in the bigs.

Eric Hosmer or Logan Morrisson

**GoldenSeals** · March 4, 2009, 8:21 AM

Depending on the situation. If we\'re in a draft, I\'d rather have the big Hawaiian, because you could get him much later, or on your Waiver Wire.

If I had to protect one of the two, would protect Butler and try to trade him.

The Big Hawaiian has some awesome power that could rival some of the best sluggers.

David Price or Clayton Kershaw?

**jackalope** · March 4, 2009, 4:12 PM

Price. Past 2 seasons, Kershaw.

Mark Aviles or Lastings Milledge

**J Status** · March 4, 2009, 10:28 PM

I still love Milledge\'s upside and he seems so close to breaking out after last season\'s performance. Aviles might have topped out.

Eric Young Jr. or Michael Bourn?

**Ogie O** · March 4, 2009, 11:13 PM

E.Y. Jr because his dad wore the most ridiculous suits on Baseball Tonight.

Well, he\'s also a switch-hitting speed with power and a decent BA type of guy that\'ll benefit from Coor\'s one day?

:P

Rich Harden (now) or Ben Sheets (post-op)

**jackalope** · March 10, 2009, 8:40 PM

I\'ll get this started again.

I\'d go for Harden now - I think he\'s got more upside than Sheets.
Good comparison cause either one could get a hangnail at any moment! :S

Maglio Ordonez or Bobby Abreu

**GoldenSeals** · March 10, 2009, 11:06 PM

Abreu gets the edge because of the SB.

Dan Haren or Francisco Liriano?

**imported_ddp** · March 11, 2009, 3:57 PM

HAREN!!!!!

Cliff Lee or Jake Peavy!
(this is actually a trade I\'m considering!)

**jackalope** · March 11, 2009, 4:51 PM

*cough* Peavy *cough* - dont know why it\'s being considered!

I\'ll post in a sec with one to continue the thread.

**jackalope** · March 11, 2009, 5:02 PM

E. Santana or E. Voloqez

**imported_ddp** · March 11, 2009, 5:13 PM

Voloqez

Ludwick or Ellsbury?

haha

**GoldenSeals** · March 11, 2009, 7:47 PM

Ervin Santana - he\'s taken that step forward we\'ve all been waiting for for so long.

Papelbon or Mariano?

**imported_ddp** · March 11, 2009, 9:20 PM

paplebon
what about Ludwick or Ellsbury?!!

**jackalope** · March 12, 2009, 7:32 AM

ddp wrote:

paplebon
what about Ludwick or Ellsbury?!!

Tisk Tisk. DJKiang skipped mine last page as well... something about not going to the last post before responding.. hrmmm

Ellsbury.

I\'ll rehash one that was skipped by DJ on Pg. 6...

Eric Hosmer (worth the wait) or Logan Morrison (should be up next season)

**GoldenSeals** · March 12, 2009, 8:29 AM

With Hosmer only having 3 games under his belt, from what I can find anyway, and Morrison having a few years worth of stats, and in the Florida system, I\'m going to say Morrison.

Morrison\'s power numbers jumped up in 2007, but took a slight decline in 2008. However all his other numbers are steadily increasing for the better. He\'s showing a good walk rate, contact, and batting eye, which could translate to him being a consistent .300 hitter. I\'m not convinced he\'ll be up next year, but you never know with no real 1B in Florida.

Between the two, Morrison is displaying all the right tools, so why not grab the one up first?

As for Ludwick vs. Ellsbury, I\'ll go with Ellsbury, only for the fact that he has higher trade value than Ludwick. Ludwick\'s power numbers are for real, but not convinced he\'s a near .300 hitter. In a keeper league, where young guys are overpriced, Ellsbury should fetch more return.

Brian McCann vs Geovany Soto?

Goalie Post is now available for your Apple/Android devices!

Thread: Let\'s play: Who would you rather keep?

Thread Tools