Stamkos+ for Fleury, Ryan and Toews

[indianapwns]

For the league in my signature.

My: Stamkos, Michalek and Lehtonen
His: Toews, Ryan and Fleury

I'm losing the best player in the deal, but gaining a lot of depth and upgrading in goal. My question is, which side would you prefer? Is this a fair trade for both sides?

Thanks for your help, and rep will follow!

[theslymonkey]

For the league in my signature.

My: Stamkos, Michalek and Lehtonen
His: Toews, Ryan and Fleury

I'm losing the best player in the deal, but gaining a lot of depth and upgrading in goal. My question is, which side would you prefer? Is this a fair trade for both sides?

Thanks for your help, and rep will follow!

I would take the Toews side without question. Even though Stamkos is a stud, you still would win this deal.

Stamkos>Toews (barely)
Michalek<Ryan
Lehtonen<<Fleury

If I was you I'd do it. I think Ryan is due for a break out very soon.

[blayze]

Stamkos is the #1 keeper in my books, but Toews + Ryan + Fleury is massive overpayment.

I would pull the trigger on that in a second.

[dmvincent]

I would take the Toews side without question. Even though Stamkos is a stud, you still would win this deal.

Stamkos>Toews (barely)
Michalek<Ryan
Lehtonen<<Fleury

If I was you I'd do it. I think Ryan is due for a break out very soon.

I agree with this statement.

[synergy989]

Stamkos>Toews (barely)

Really? Stammer is definitely better than Toews...

1) Stammer 40+G season, 50+ Goal season - Toews 34G highest season
2) Stammer 90 point player - Toews 70 point player
3) Stammer High 200 SOG - Toews Low 200 SOG

only thing Toews has on Stamkos is +/-

But to not get off topic - that deal is for sure over paying for him and would pull the trigger for sure.

[DerekReese]

I would make this deal as it is a good deal for you.