Keep 1 goalie out of the following 3 (REPS!)

[skotchek]

I have 3 quality goalies, however my keeper league is limited and only allows me to keep 1.

I can only keep one of the following:

Schneider: I came into the season with Schneider as my keeper, and he has not disappointed at all. He's got a 2.19 GAA and .928 SV% on a brutal Devils team, which does not look to be any better next season.

Bishop: 36 wins, 2.34 GAA, .915 SV%. Extremely quality on an elite team. But Vasilevskiy is undoubtedly the golden boy in Tampa and I can see a 70/30 scenario or worse next year.

Dubnyk: I was incredibly fortunate to pick up Dubnyk when he was traded to the Wild, and we all obviously known what he's done. 33 wins (and counting), 2.07 GAA, .930 SV%. Should win the Hart Trophy. But his past is quite sketchy and I don't know if he's a sure thing going forward.

I also have Eddie Lack, but he's not in the conversation. Who do you keep??

[LordoftheRinks]

The good news - in a 10-team league, there will always be options to pick up at least one more quality goalie. I would take Schneider as your keeper - his win totals may not be as big as Bishop's but he's the horse in NJ (they have NO ONE else) and his peripherals are excellent. He's sound, durable, and there's no one to usurp him.

[skiteam14]

Schneider has great peripherals but I think I'd go Dubnyk. I see him sticking around in Minny and with a good team in front of him I'm not so sure it's a flash in the pan. I think he could be excellent next season over 82 games.

[The Bottlenecker]

The choice is between Bishop and Schneider IMO. Dubnyk doesn't even have a contract for next year yet, and even if he gets one, I see him being a Mike Smith type guy (one great season, followed by mediocrity). Bishop gets the wins, Schneider the GAA and SV%. You are right to assume that Vasilevsky will see more playing time next year which should take away from Bishop's win total. Schenider's team won't get any better, but he has fared well despite the lack of offense in NJ.

Schneider is your best bet here.

[Jouko-Pouko]

Since your league tracks so many goalie stats (W, SV, SO, GAA, SV%), Schneider is your choice. In a league with only Wins and Shutouts, he wouldn't be. Schneider might not get lots of wins but he's really good in all other stats.

[skiteam14]

Didn't see SV as a cat. This favors Schneider who is like the Pac-man of rubber.

[Daydream Nation]

Schneider - take the most proven talent

[skotchek]

I think the opinions here are right on, Schneider is a proven workhorse. Bishop and Dubnyk are just so intriguing but I agree with Schneider being to go-to guy.

[One87]

I have 3 quality goalies, however my keeper league is limited and only allows me to keep 1.

I can only keep one of the following:

Schneider: I came into the season with Schneider as my keeper, and he has not disappointed at all. He's got a 2.19 GAA and .928 SV% on a brutal Devils team, which does not look to be any better next season.

Bishop: 36 wins, 2.34 GAA, .915 SV%. Extremely quality on an elite team. But Vasilevskiy is undoubtedly the golden boy in Tampa and I can see a 70/30 scenario or worse next year.

Dubnyk: I was incredibly fortunate to pick up Dubnyk when he was traded to the Wild, and we all obviously known what he's done. 33 wins (and counting), 2.07 GAA, .930 SV%. Should win the Hart Trophy. But his past is quite sketchy and I don't know if he's a sure thing going forward.

I also have Eddie Lack, but he's not in the conversation. Who do you keep??

Vasilevskiy is a bonafide threat. I would trade Bishop before it's too late. In terms of "keep" I would rank:

Schneider
Dubnyk
Bishop