HUberdeau or Carter over the next 2-3 years and beyond

[slapshot99]

G, A, Pts, PPG, PPA, +/-, SOG, PIM, Hits

Who would you rather have over the next 2-3 years: jeff carter or huberdeau?

[Yonald]

Huberdeau for me. Carter in LA's system isn't what he used to be in Philly. He is scoring this year so far but I doubt he can keep up his high shooting %. Huberdeau might match his points this year and should only go up from here

[Zorro]

Huberdeau is only going to get better and better. Give me Huberdeau over Carter..

[slapshot99]

Thanks for the quick replies. Rep to both of you. Thats where i'm leaning as well. Anyone brave enough to give realistic projections for both over the next 3 years? Where would hub top out (ie career year)?

[Atomic Wedgy]

I think Huberdeau is the clear choice here. I think he will be a point per game player within 3 years.

Carter will coast as much as he can, doing just enough not to be publicly ridiculed. He'll coast to 60-70 points each year for the next 3 years. He could be a consistent ppg player, but that would involve way too much effort.

[Zorro]

Originally Posted by Atomic Wedgy

I think Huberdeau is the clear choice here. I think he will be a point per game player within 3 years.

Carter will coast as much as he can, doing just enough not to be publicly ridiculed. He'll coast to 60-70 points each year for the next 3 years. He could be a consistent ppg player, but that would involve way too much effort.

Well said Atomic, you are right on with this analysis..

[Essej]

As soon as next season I like Huberdeau.