Goalie for D

[Cadence]

For my league in sig, another owner just lost Lehtonen (one of his two Gs), and he has a pretty good lineup of D-men. I am only holding onto 3 Dmen in a roto league so I need a fourth.

Here are his d-men

Letang
Shattenkirk
Yandle
Beauchemin
Kostka

Other players of interest include Kessel, Moulson, and Tavares.

I'm wondering which goalie should I attempt to trade and for what in return. Alternatively I could package a center with it to get a better haul. What do you think of these offers I could make?

1) Henrik Sedin + Faulk for Letang + Shattenkirk
2) Backstrom + Kesler for Shattenkirk
3) Kipprusoff for Yandle
4) Kipprusoff for Shattenkirk

[redprince]

1) I think you are clearly getting the better end with Letang and Shat, but seems unlikely to be accepted.
2) This is the most probable scenario IMO, and if you can afford to lose Backstrom, do it. In the long run this could be overpaying.
3) His is ok too, but Yandle has not been impressive at all, so a bit risky.
4) This trade I would never accept if I had Shattenkirk...

[Cadence]

Originally Posted by redprince

1) I think you are clearly getting the better end with Letang and Shat, but seems unlikely to be accepted.
2) This is the most probable scenario IMO, and if you can afford to lose Backstrom, do it. In the long run this could be overpaying.
3) His is ok too, but Yandle has not been impressive at all, so a bit risky.
4) This trade I would never accept if I had Shattenkirk...

Thnks - do you have any other suggestions?

[redprince]

I'd pair Kipper with Kesler or Faulk and try to get Shattenkirk, if the owner does not bite on other offers. To get Letang and Shattenkirk I'd pair H. Sedin with Backstrom, or Kipper with Sedin, I think it's more likely one of these get accepted, especially of they are looking for a goalie.