Hartnell/Gaborik/Keith for Ovechkin - too much?

[Heaton]

Looking to upgrade my keepers and while Ovechkin has been underwhelming for a little while he still has immense value especially keeper wise. Is Hartnell, Gaborik and Keith too much to give up?

[robmyatt]

Yes that is too much.take out hartnell and it is closer.

[DerekReese]

Gaborik and Keith by themselves could be too much for Ovy. I would look at getting something else back too.

[Pengwin7]

Originally Posted by Heaton

Looking to upgrade my keepers and while Ovechkin has been underwhelming for a little while he still has immense value especially keeper wise. Is Hartnell, Gaborik and Keith too much to give up?

Not enough info.
It depends on total league keeper quantity & the fantasy league (scoring) categories.

In a 8-team league, where each team keeps 3 (24 total league keepers)... Ovechkin may be the only guy that is even keeper worth.
In a 14-team league, where each team keeps 12 (168 total league keepers)... I'd definitely prefer the Hartnell/Gaborik/Keith side.

[Heaton]

Originally Posted by Pengwin7

Not enough info.
It depends on total league keeper quantity & the fantasy league (scoring) categories.

In a 8-team league, where each team keeps 3 (24 total league keepers)... Ovechkin may be the only guy that is even keeper worth.
In a 14-team league, where each team keeps 12 (168 total league keepers)... I'd definitely prefer the Hartnell/Gaborik/Keith side.

It's a 14 team league where teams keep 4 Forwards, 2 D 1 UTIL (F or D) and a goalie

My keepers at the moment are:
F: Giroux, Couture, Kopitar, Hartnell
D: Schultz, Edler
U: Gaborik
G: Lundqvist

If I acquired Ovechkin my keepers would most likely be:
F: Giroux, Ovechkin, Couture, Kopitar
D: Schultz, Edler
U: Marchand
G: Lundqvist

Forwards/Defensemen Stat Category Value
Goals (G) 3.0
Assists (A) 2.0
Plus/Minus (+/-) 0.3
Penalty Minutes (PIM) 0.4
Powerplay Points (PPP) 0.5
Shorthanded Points (SHP) 1.0
Game-Winning Goals (GWG) 1.0
Shots on Goal (SOG) 0.3
Faceoffs Won (FW) 0.05
Hits (HIT) 0.1

[Pengwin7]

So... keeper-wise, you are considering the following comparison:
Ovechkin/Marchand
vs.
Gaborik/Hartnell

That's the real question.
It's a pretty level trade, to be honest. Both sides are good.

By actual value, Gaborik/Hartnell are probably better.
This is a coin-flip. I personally own Gaborik & Hartnell in a couple leagues... so I've grown fond of them.

I don't know... your call.

[Heaton]

Originally Posted by Pengwin7

So... keeper-wise, you are considering the following comparison:
Ovechkin/Marchand
vs.
Gaborik/Hartnell

That's the real question.
It's a pretty level trade, to be honest. Both sides are good.

By actual value, Gaborik/Hartnell are probably better.
This is a coin-flip. I personally own Gaborik & Hartnell in a couple leagues... so I've grown fond of them.

I don't know... your call.

Gaborik is obviously a scary keeper, from year to year it can be either great or extremely frustrating. As for Hartnell, I'm a huge fan of his, but is he closer to the guy we saw last year? Or the 50 point guy that we normally see? I think out of everyone involved Ovechkin has the highest upside.