Tavares vs. Ovie

[am78]

Going back and forth with a team in my pts only pool


I want his Ovie and an upgrade in net

So far the offer to me is his Ovie, Ward for my Tavares, Hiller

Peripheral goalie stats do not matter so ita all wins and shutouts (2 for w and 3 more for so)

I want a little more so he has players like Voracek and E Kane that I may want as a 3rd part to the deal...Am I getting greedy or am I realistic

My Hiller, Tavares, and M Foligno for His Ward, Ovie and either E Kane/ Voracek

I think I am over stretching but not sure how much to value Ovie right now

[rataylor22]

Points only, this is a goalie upgrading trade. Tavares is just better than Ovie. If Hiller comes back strong and sees the majority of starts in Anaheim, you straight up lose this trade. Ward is a safer bet in goal. Based on Hiller being the backup, this trade is fair and asking for Kane is reaching. Based on Hiller being a starter, I wouldn't even consider the trade unless the Kane and Foligno pieces were in it.

2010-11
JT - 29G, 38A, 67P
OV - 32G, 53A, 85P

2011-12
JT - 31G, 50A, 81P
OV - 38G, 27A, 65P

2013-12
JT - 7G, 8A, 15P
OV - 5G, 5A, 10P

So keeping in consideration Ovie normally scores more goals than assists, or at least has them very even, the only year of the last 3 he has beat JT in points is when Ovie collected an unusual number of assists. Keeping that in mind with career trajectory, I'd rather have JT every day.