Need some advice....big trade

[baumer]

I am thinking of moving St. Louis.

I have three good offers.

One is:

Lupul, Gagner (Edm) 1st 2014 and a 6th 2013
for St. Louis

or

Henrik Sedin, Brad Richards for St. Louis

or JVR, Richards, 3rd 13 and 10th 14 for St. Louis

I'm contending this year, pool and struture is in my signature.

First, would any of you do the deal and second which one is better?

Thanks and rep to as many as I can.

[gainerama]

If you're contending and trying to win this year, you have to go with the Sedin & Richards deal. St. Louis is still going to put up crazy points but this will give you a bit more depth with strong front line players.

[finnys_fanatsy]

Sedin and Richrds if you are competing, hell even if your not competing Sedin and Richards is a decent return.

[baumer]

Ok, thank you for the advice....rep tp both of you.

[baumer]

No one's a big fan of the Lupul and Gagner deal?

[Instant Karma]

Originally Posted by baumer

No one's a big fan of the Lupul and Gagner deal?

Not me. If you're contending, I'd either do the Sedin/Richards deal or just stick w/ St. Louis.

[dmvincent]

Originally Posted by gainerama

If you're contending and trying to win this year, you have to go with the Sedin & Richards deal. St. Louis is still going to put up crazy points but this will give you a bit more depth with strong front line players.

I have nothing further.

[Bass56]

Originally Posted by finnys_fanatsy

Sedin and Richrds if you are competing, hell even if your not competing Sedin and Richards is a decent return.

Both these guys can potentially outpoint St. Louis this year and in the coming seasons. To me it almost looks like a 2 for 1. I would be all over this deal!

[baumer]

Thanks guys,

So it looks like the deal is going to be done....I gave rep to all of you.

The final deal is Henrik Sedin, B. Richards, 3rd pick in 2013

For

St. Louis and a 9th in 13 and a 10th in 14.

Thanks for your help

[Axeman33]

Originally Posted by baumer

Thanks guys,

So it looks like the deal is going to be done....I gave rep to all of you.

The final deal is Henrik Sedin, B. Richards, 3rd pick in 2013

For

St. Louis and a 9th in 13 and a 10th in 14.

Thanks for your help

Solid return for Marty! Well done!