Crosby for Price, Daniel Sedin, Dan Boyle?

[bergs]

I got offered this trade where i am giving up crosby and I'm stumped. Last time i gave up sid, he had a ridiculous year, but it think this is just amazing for me.

categories are: g, a, pts, ppp, shots, blocks, wins, sv%, gaa, shutouts

my goalies are varlamov, theodore, smith (IR for now)

let me know what you think!

[Filadelphia]

Take it. Goalies account for 4 out of 9 categories and you could use some help back there. Not to mention Sedin should have around 40-50 points where I can't see Crosby breaking 60. Throw in Boyle who is playing on the red hot sharks and you come out on top.

[yougo]

Originally Posted by bergs

I got offered this trade where i am giving up crosby and I'm stumped. Last time i gave up sid, he had a ridiculous year, but it think this is just amazing for me.

categories are: g, a, pts, ppp, shots, blocks, wins, sv%, gaa, shutouts

my goalies are varlamov, theodore, smith (IR for now)

let me know what you think!

This is a serious offer. He came to you and offered this straight up? Is that an offer you are counting of offering him?

I'll weight in.

First of all, I would love to see his roster because he might own a better defenseman than Boyle. I love Boyle but he's getting old and if you are going to deal Crosby you better make sure that you are getting the max in return.

Same thing with Daniel Sedin. I'm curious to see what other forwards he owns. Not sure how many elite years he still has in him. I still am a big believer in the Sedin and I feel like they still have atleast 3 year of being top players in the league. But again, Daniel is not 25 year old like Crosby.

Price is the absolute perfect match for you I think. He's young and got a lot of great years ahead of him.

Who are you gonna have to drop if you make this deal?

Lastly, I need more info about your team and league to give you an honest answer.

[bergs]

my roster:
krejci, crosby, tanguay, glencross, okposo, eberle, duchene, wheeler, brunner, zetterberg, st louis, hartnell (IR), pietrangelo, streit, diaz, hamhuis, theodore, varlamov, smith (IR)

his roster:
joe thornton, RNH, evander kane, daniel sedin, seguin, versteeg, kadri, grabner, conacher, purcell, erik karlsson, dan boyle, suter, green, price, luongo, schneider

[yougo]

How many teams? Is it a full keeper? Daily starts?

Personally, I owned Crosby in any given league, I would either ask in return one of Stamkos/Malkin/Giroux with another player that would upgrade my team.

In this case, your team does lack in depth IMO and while I don't like the idea of trading Crosby, so I would start with a starting point of Karlsson-Price. The forward you are going to receive should absolutely be no slouch. Seguin-RNH-E.Kane. His team is stacked, if he wants to take a run at Crosby makes sure he pays the price. He can afford to overpay for the Kid when I look at his roster.

Throw-in the players you were going to drop to even out the bodies. My final answer is don't move Crosby unless you get a MAJOR upgrade on your roster.

[bergs]

oh sorry..its a 4 person keeper, 10 team league with 2C, 2LW, 2RW, 4D, 2UTIL, 2G

[GretzkysMullet]

In a keep four I'd hang on to Crosby.

[ridinryan44]

Originally Posted by GretzkysMullet

In a keep four I'd hang on to Crosby.

**** ya. That's a great offer but you can fix your goalie situation in the draft. Only way I'd do this is if it was near the end of the season and this move would help you win. In a keep four league, keeping Crosby is a must.

[bergs]

ok thanks guys! didnt wanna jump into a mistake without consulting the "fantasy gods" aka this forum.