Which side? B.Rich/E.Kane/Enstrom or Nuge/Versteeg/Yandle

[HockeyProphet]

Pts only, keeper.. sig below.. what side would you prefer? Now and in the future?

[YKPV PWR SLD]

This season and the future: Nuge/Versteeg/Yandle

You are upgrading Enstrom to Yandle.
Upgrading B Rich to Nuge. The only place you lose some ground is Kane for Versteeg. But even that isn't too crazy. Plus Nuge and Yandle are much younger.

[joeb323]

Keeper league I like the Nuge/Versteeg/Yandle side. Versteeg is the weak link but you make up for it with Nuge and Yandle who are both solid keepers.

[jman]

Ya, I'd take the Nuge side too. He's the best points player in the deal. I think Enstrom is more consistent than Yandle but I think Yandle's ceiling is higher.

This might be one of those 'Oh duh' questions but I'm drawing a blank on who B. Rich is...

[Pengwin7]

Enstrom vs. Yandle is even. Let's take that out.

Here's how I'd value them for the next 3 years:
70pts RNH
70pts B.Richards
60pts E.Kane
50pts Versteeg

I'm in the minority, but I prefer B.Richards/E.Kane/Enstrom.

[HockeyProphet]

thanks for the opinions.. I'm still on the fence about this potential deal.. I find it pretty close so was seeing what the verdict was for other people.

[lucifer316]

maybe try to get something better than versteeg or offer something less than kane

[fantasyhockeygeek]

I'm with Pengwin - I like the Richards/Enstrom/Kane side, and actually by a pretty fair margin.

Enstrom and Yandle are a wash.
Evander Kane should be 15-20 points above Versteeg.

RNH should have an edge over Richards, but how much? A few points.

I'll disclose that I'm higher on E Kane than most, and think his upside is in the low 90's.

[HockeyProphet]

Well now the trade has formally been proposed to me. My thoughts are does Richards see a decline soon? Or does see a Nuge a big incline? Enstrom injuries? And how does E.Kane pan out, everybody speaks ill of his attitude, but he does continue to put up points so I dunno.

And because of my keeper situation I could package a 3 for 2 keepers.. but do you guys think I could get more out of richards, ekane and enstrom then Nuge and Yandle?

[Russian Rocket 10]

Richards is only 32 years old which means he's got more than a few years of solid points to put up.
I'll also say that I slightly prefer Enstrom over Yandle.
The E. Kane upgrade over Versteeg is huge IMO.
I'll take the Richards/Kane/Enstrom side...though not by much.