prospect trade

[kane12345]

hey guys, this is a trade for the team in my sig

i trade

bishop
1 of khudobin or gibson (who do you think i should put?) thinking gibson

for

Frk
Nieto

if i do this with gibson i will still have

backstrom emery khudobin playing in the pro
and
markstrom missiean perhonen ericksson on the farm

does this leave my goaltending too weak?

thanks in advance

[Buck Fush]

If that is John Gibson, do not trade him! In a 20 team league, goalies (even prospect goalies) have to come at a premium. I just don't see the point in doing this trade, as Frk and Nieto are far (very far) from being sure things.

Edit: just noticed you only play one goalie... Still don't like the deal.

[kane12345]

Originally Posted by Buck Fush

If that is John Gibson, do not trade him! In a 20 team league, goalies (even prospect goalies) have to come at a premium. I just don't see the point in doing this trade, as Frk and Nieto are far (very far) from being sure things.

Edit: just noticed you only play one goalie... Still don't like the deal.

chris gibson, the LAK one forgot to mention that

i dont have any elite forward or D prospects thats the only thing im looking at right now and with markstrom coming up too

[Axeman33]

I'd definitely be looking for at least one established player in return if I am moving 2 goalies (prospects or not). Bishop is already pencilled in to back up Anderson so you are giving up 1 NHL calibre goalie and one goalie prospect for 2 prospect skaters.

As mentioned earlier, goalies in a 20 team league certainly hold more value then skaters. Don't sell them short. Get someone established in return.

[Carcillo]

I like your goalie prospects better than the two forward prospects you'd be getting. Nieto and Frk are miles away from becoming NHL'ers and while I like Nieto's upside it's not anything special. Keep your goalies.