Ovi, Hall, Schiltz and 2 goalies.

[TheBigJankowski]

I Had counter offered the same manager:

My Schultz and Hall

For

His Ovi


He has now countered with:

My Schultz, Hall and Schneider

For

His Ovi and Backstrom (Min) and he will be dropping Phaneuf

Here is a recap of his roster.

Matt Duchene, Derek Roy, Ryan Getzlaf, Joe Thornton, Curtis Glencross, Thomas Vanek, Rick Nash, Alex Ovechkin, Sam Gagner, Jakub Voracek, Ales Hemsky,
Patric Hornqvist, Oliver Ekman-Larsson, Cam Fowler, Dion Phaneuf, Ryan Ellis. Kiprusoff, Backstrom
Farm: Jonathan Huberdeau, Sean Couturier

Thoughts? Thank you so much for all the advice and for hopefully more to come.

[arctic_rogue]

How many goalies do you start?

If it's two, I'd try to swap Schneider out with Hossa in the deal and keep Schneider in Hossa's spot.

I love the fact that you're upgrading Hall to OV. But I'd really try to keep Schneider (if it's a start 2 goalie league)

If not, I'd do the deal - it's golden in a limited keeper.

[TheBigJankowski]

We do start 2 goalies. I can only keep 2 goalies on our roster. Thanks for your reply Artic Rouge.

[TheBigJankowski]

Sorry Arctic Rouge.

[arctic_rogue]

What's the point breakdown for the different categories. It could make a difference.

[TheBigJankowski]

1 point for a goal and for an assist.
2 points for a win and 3 points for a shut out.

[The Hockey Hitman]

No I wouldnt make that trade. Stick with what you have.

[arctic_rogue]

Originally Posted by TheBigJankowski

1 point for a goal and for an assist.
2 points for a win and 3 points for a shut out.

Definitely hold onto and keep Schneider.

In a normal year... Schneider - 35 Wins + 5 SO = 70+15 = 95

I don't see any way that Hossa gets to 95 points in any way, shape, or form.

See if you can include Hossa in a deal for OV.

[Call of Doughty]

Originally Posted by TheBigJankowski

I Had counter offered the same manager:

My Schultz and Hall

For

His Ovi


He has now countered with:

My Schultz, Hall and Schneider

For

His Ovi and Backstrom (Min) and he will be dropping Phaneuf

Agree. Keep Schneider here, especially if you dress two goalies weekly. He's far too valuable.

For Ovie I might try your Hall/Wheeler/Schultz straight up for Ovie. Or Hall/Wheeler/Shatts for Ovie + a utility player coming back. Frankly I love Wheeler and would rather see you offer one of Patches/Hossa/Marleau in a deal here. And I think Schultz is going to be a dandy and he's in an unreal place going fwd with the Oilers. With Piets in your lineup, I thought Shatts could be expendable here. Part of me also feels you are fine as you sit now. I would make a serious offer for Ovie, but wouldn't bend over backwards to get him. How many do you dress weekly?

[Call of Doughty]

Originally Posted by TheBigJankowski

He has now countered with:

My Schultz, Hall and Schneider

For

His Ovi and Backstrom (Min) and he will be dropping Phaneuf

Just to confirm, I would NOT do this deal. You're giving up a little too much.
Try to swoon him for Ovie without giving up Schneider in the deal. You have far too many assests you could use instead of Schneider.