D man trade thoughts

[TheCamelToews]

I want to upgrade my d men, and someone offered me this.

I give:
Moulson, B Smith
for
Hemsky, and Keith

I countered with
Moulson, B Smith
for
AP and Hemsky

League Info
13 team, Roto, Forward and D stats are: G, A, +/-, PPP, Shots, Hits

Would either of these trades interest you?

[hockeyrobot]

I would not want any part of Ales Hemsky in any kind of league. Who else does he have?

[9601]

Originally Posted by hockeyrobot

I would not want any part of Ales Hemsky in any kind of league. Who else does he have?

Ditto. He'll be reduced to third line RW by about 10 games in

[Bnhershy]

not a fan of Hemsky in any format. but i loooooove AP. if you can get any sort of upgrade on hemsky while still snagging piet, go for it

[TheCamelToews]

I am seeing what he wants for Neal and Keith instead. He seems interested in Moulson, so we will see where it goes!

[ericdaoust]

Originally Posted by TheCamelToews

I am seeing what he wants for Neal and Keith instead. He seems interested in Moulson, so we will see where it goes!

Just don't buy into Keith's 69 point season and overpay. He's a 40-50 point guy.

[Shoeless]

I like your counter offer - AP is an emerging stud who hits a fair amount. Likely never going to be any cheaper than this if you can get the deal done. I wouldn't do the Keith trade though.

[RizzeeDizzee]

I agree about AP - do what you can to land him, even if it means also having to take a guy you don't really want. I firmly believe that AP his only begun to show what he'll achieve, both in terms of fantasy hockey and "real hockey".

[Skin Blues]

Hemsky is a throw-in, so consider the deal without him even being included. Presumably there are dozens of players on waivers that would be an upgrade over what is essentially a poor man's Andy McDonald. I'd do this deal in a second.