Top 10 Keeper League C

[KoHolga]

1- Malkin
2- Crosby
3- Stamkons
4- Tavares
5- Giroux
6- Backstrom
7- H. Sedin
8- E.Staal
9 - Getzlaf
10- Thorton

Benn, Kopitar, Dats, RNH

I dont see how backstrom is not on some of ur guys list... he is so young still and he has hit 100+ twice... no way he shouldnt be high on this list

I also prob put thorton on here and most people would disagree but this guys continuously out points ppl and is a huge pp threat and he never gets injured

[metaldude26]

1- Malkin
2- Crosby
3- Stamkons
4- Tavares
5- Giroux
6- Backstrom
7- H. Sedin
8- E.Staal
9 - Getzlaf
10- Thorton

Benn, Kopitar, Dats, RNH

I dont see how backstrom is not on some of ur guys list... he is so young still and he has hit 100+ twice... no way he shouldnt be high on this list

I also prob put thorton on here and most people would disagree but this guys continuously out points ppl and is a huge pp threat and he never gets injured

When was the second time?

[gfhyde]

When was the second time?

There almost definitely was no second time. Back when the Caps were worthwhile, he hit 88pts (08-09), then 101pts (09-10). 2011 he hit 65. His entire success is based around Ovechkin not being a giant piece of crap.

[4horsemen]

#1 - Sidney Crosby...

...no one else matters.

I was just scrolling down to write this when....bamm....you beat me to it! Nice

Crosby is in a league of his own. Any list that doesn't start with him loses me completely. Malkin vs Stamkos is a good debate for 2 and 3

[Dennis4022]

1- Malkin
2- Crosby
3- Stamkons
4- Tavares
5- Giroux
6- Backstrom
7- H. Sedin
8- E.Staal
9 - Getzlaf
10- Thorton

Benn, Kopitar, Dats, RNH

I dont see how backstrom is not on some of ur guys list... he is so young still and he has hit 100+ twice... no way he shouldnt be high on this list

I also prob put thorton on here and most people would disagree but this guys continuously out points ppl and is a huge pp threat and he never gets injured

Have you watched any Washington games in the last two years? Backstrom does not deserve to be on that list just because he was able to pass the puck to Ovechkin some time ago. Obviously he has even lost that!

[blayze]

When was the second time?

Obviously he's referring to the future when Ovie returns to his 60+ goal form and Green re-activates beast mode again. All they need is a new coach who will bring a fresh system that complements their strengths. Duh...

[angus]

Great feedback, gents. Going to get to work to this tomorrow. Dobber's covering me for tomorrow's ramblings as I'm going to be on the road.

[dmvincent]

Stamkos
Crosby
Malkin
Giroux
Tavares
Toews
H. Sedin
E. Staal
Getzlaf
RNH

[TheWhale]

Crosby
Stamkos
Malkin
Giroux
Tavares
E Staal
Backstrom
Benn
Toews
Getzlaf

HM: Kopitar, Dats, H Sedin

[Gaborlick]

Crosby
Malkin
Stamkos
Tavares
Giroux
....
Toews
Sedin
Duchene
RNH
Getzlaf

[Laendarian]

1. Crosby
2. Malkin
3. Stamkos
4. Tavares
5. Giroux
6. E Staal
7. Getzlaf
8. Kopitar
9. Toews
10. Backstrom

HM's to: Toews, Sedin, Datsyuk, Zetterberg, Skinner, Spezza, Benn

C is so deep, after the first 5 it gets pretty tough.

[4horsemen]

Message to those who do not have Crosby at #1.... what game is it you guys are watching because it obviously isn't 2013 NHL hockey?

[metaldude26]

Message to those who do not have Crosby at #1.... what game is it you guys are watching because it obviously isn't 2013 NHL hockey?

I respect their decision to be afraid of Crosby's concussion woes just so long as it isn't based on, "he's one hit away from never playing again," for the simple reason that that statement applies to everyone. I just personally think the upside with Crosby is so drastic that I'd take a chance on him over anyone else without concern.

[bondon]

I don't have the patience right now to sit down and think about who my top 10 would be, but I just want to make the point that for all of the people probably thinking players are getting slighted for not being included on this list, that the C position is incredibly deep so there are gonna be A LOT of people that have to be left off. I mean 5 or 6 of the top 10 Cs are top 10 picks in fantasy leagues to begin with, to put things into perspective.

[blayze]

Message to those who do not have Crosby at #1.... what game is it you guys are watching because it obviously isn't 2013 NHL hockey?

What are you basing that bold statement on? Are you referring to the MONSTROUS two point lead that Crosby has over Stamkos in the scoring lead?

I can't fault anyone for placing Crosby at #1, but the thought process is pretty straight-forward to me.

You have Crosby, who is the best player in the world. Without a doubt the most "upside" potential. Having said that, most people on this forum talk about Crosby's "upside" as if he's going to imminently break out and score 150 points or something. The reality is that his peak in EIGHT seasons has been 120... and he's never come close to that total again. Naturally the response most of you will give to this is "well he's been injured for extended periods in 3 of the last 5 season!". My response to that is... well then, you just answered your own question as to why I don't have him at #1!

Then you have Stamkos, who is the second best player in the world (sorry Malkinators). He is healthy as an ox, is one of the best conditioned players in the NHL, arguably has more room for growth than Crosby, AND he's an automatic lock for 50 goals and 90 points every single freaking season. I don't have to worry about him getting hit, I don't have to worry about him missing games, I don't have to worry about who he's playing with... I don't have to worry period. And personally, I think he has yet to even hit his ceiling and soon enough he'll posting 100+ just like Crosby and Malkin, but that's just me.

From that perspective, Stamkos at #1 makes sense.

Flame on.