Bogo vs Gardiner vs Wizzer

[tripel]

how do you rank them in a keeper?
i am re-calibrating for next year, having fallen on mighty hard times this year.
traded Selanne & Vishnovsky for Wheeler and a 4th, then traded Brodeur & Brown for Bernier. Now I have to move one of these Dmen (maybe 2) and/or Turris...
would love any input
thanks

[bizzl]

If you can move Wisniewski I'd look at that, obviously depending on what you're getting back. He's such a huge injury risk that it almost doesn't matter how good he is offensively. I actually consider him to be the best fantasy defenseman of the 3, but the injuries are too much, and he ends up last on the list. Bogosian was supposed to be a monster fantasy guy, and he might develop into one yet, but I think the clock is ticking down and Gardiner would be the guy I'd want here.

[havanablast21]

If you can move Wisniewski I'd look at that, obviously depending on what you're getting back. He's such a huge injury risk that it almost doesn't matter how good he is offensively. I actually consider him to be the best fantasy defenseman of the 3, but the injuries are too much, and he ends up last on the list. Bogosian was supposed to be a monster fantasy guy, and he might develop into one yet, but I think the clock is ticking down and Gardiner would be the guy I'd want here.

Agreed. I love Wiz and place most value on him when he's healthy...but i've been burnt 3 years in a row by the bab.

I'm not a believer in Bogosian.

Take a chance on Gards. The path is clear for his eventual rise to fantasy relevancy as soon as tomorrow.

[tripel]

Thanks both
That's the way I was leaning too

[Zorro]

You can't go wrong with both Bogo and Gardiner!!

[tripel]

You can't go wrong with both Bogo and Gardiner!!

Thanks, thats what im thinkin

Question -- how do you see MDZ in this rank?
Is he significantly higher than ZB ?

Im considering a big offer to throw all my non keepers at a guy for him

Would be enstrom, kronwall, gardiner, mdz (instead of bogo)