Need your advice!

[kevinsane]

Keeper league, three goalies, no movement during the season, two farm spots. Wins 2 points, shutouts 5 points.

With SO's at 5 each, our League is very goalie driven.

I have:

Miller
Lehtonen
Smith
Giguere
C. Schneider

I'm keeping Miller and Lehtonen, putting Schneider on the farm, but who would you keep as a third? Giguere or Smith? Both face platooning issues, both have lost starting jobs, both play behind often leaky D.

What would you do?

[sportsfan23454]

who does Smith play on again?

[Shoeless]

Wow - tough call. One I would not want to make for my team. I guess the only things I think about are that TB is probably going to have a better record than Toronto but that Wilson has also designated Giggy as the starter. I would probably close my eyes, take Giggy and pray it was the right call.

[butch]

not an easy choice but I'm basing it on Smith's inability to stay healthy + the Ellis factor

I'd go with Giguere -if the leafs get on any type of a roll this year he'll be one of the reasons .

[NoUseForAName]

Giguere for me too. He got the better chance to do something good, even if I don't think any of those 2 goalies will do anything good this year.