Yeah I dunno tough choice...
I think with Kipper you have a lesser individual stat goalie, but a slightly better team. With Rinne you have a better statistical goalie, but a slightly worst offense behind him.
I kinda looked in their career splits against their division rivals (since they'll be spending the most time against their division), and there's a slight advantage to Rinne.
Kipper career(vs Oilers, Nucks, Wild and Avs)
83-52-19, 2.45 GAA, .911 sv%
Rinne career (vs Wings, Blues, Hawks, Jackets)
21-11-3, 2.30 GAA, .924 sv%
So I dunno it's a really tough call... I don't think there's gonna major difference between the two. I kinda prefer Rinne over Kipper, but I don't really have any solid reasoning for that basis.
Dobber Expert Pool Champion 2011-12