Good value for Matthews?

[Stencil]

It's point only with position requirements, 12 teams, 27 roster, 20 minors, head-to-head

Trade goes like this:

A.Matthews, 13th overall pick in 2018 prospect draft, V.Dunn, J.Armia, J.Ikonen, P.Zacha
for
B.Marchand, a lottery pick who will be between 1st and 6th overall in next 2018 prospect draft, E.Lindholm, 5th round draft pick


My take is it's a gamble on the lottery pick. If it's a top 3 pick the odds are good on Marchand's side, even if the 13th overall pick is still a top player. If it ends up being a 5th or 6th overall pick, Marchand's side probably lose since it's as much as a gamble to draft 5th then 13th and Matthews is 10 years younger then Marchand.


How do you see it?

[Mcdangles]

I'd keep Mathews. That "gamble" isn't worth it to me.

[Joker]

No go for me too. I’d need that pick to be 1st or I wouldn’t do it.

[lucafen4]

Keep Matthews. As soon as he heats up you'll have sellers remorse.

[Belexus75]

Matthews > Marchant...once that pick is ready to contribute Marchant will not be anymore...and chances of that pick being anything like Matthews are very slim...

dont do it...but its not horrible...

[als_revenge]

If you were guaranteed the first pick, I'd still keep Matthews.

[Triplea14]

Yea that's no where near enough for Matthews. Looks more like a distraction than a good offer