Need advice asap

[AlexB13]

Trade 1:
My- Nikita Kucherov, Mark Scheiffele, Erik Karlsson, Danton Heinen, John Gibson
For
His- Jakub Voracek, Anders Lee, John Klingberg, Brandon Saad, Pekka Rinne

14 teams. My league is a head to head league with a categories point system. The categories are as follows:

Forwards/Defenseman-
Goals, assists, +-, PPP, SHP, SOG

Goalies-
Wins, saves, GAA, SV%, SO


My team is:
Mcdavid
Backstrom
Sdhwartz (IR)
Heinen
Kucherov
Hornqvist
Anthanasiou
Schmaltz
Tierny
Scheiffele (IR)
Carter (IR+)

Karlsson
Giordano
Ellis
Lindholm

Gibson
Helleybuyck
Reimer

[PenguinHunter]

No!

Kucherov >> Voracek

Scheifele > Lee (Although Sheifele is injured)

Erik Karlsson > Klingberg - I know that Klingberg has had the better season to date... but still Karlsson is better.

Heinen < Saad Okay so you win one here... but Saad being better than Heinen does not make up for the difference above.

Gibson < Rinne But I still don't think this makes up for the difference of trading away Kucherov.

[Stalinism]

I wouldn't do the deal. Scheiffele is a top 10 center in the league and his team will be a contender for years to come.
Same goes for Kuch, I think he's a top 5 goal scorer in the league for the next 5 years.
Gibson is a good young starter on a defense first team
Heinen has come out of nowhere but is a good depth option
Karlsson is having a down year but is a reliable top 5 D in the league. Could be even more when he's not on Ottawa.

Your return isn't bad it's just not up to the level of what you give up. Rinne has 2 years left as the starter at most. Who knows what Saad is now, Voracek piles up the A and Lee the G but they are very much a foxy by proxy type players. Lee doesn't drive his line and I would argue that Voracek doesnt either.

[AlexB13]

Its a 1 year league, thats the thing. And goalies are so valuable. 5 goalie categories and 6 forward categories.. so rinne and helly would be an unstoppable duo. And scheiffle is out another 4-6 weeks

[Dennis]

Just no. Bad trade for you.

[vonderpibe]

Still a no from me. I think you can find a G upgrade without giving up some of the best/elite skaters.

I'd suggest not moving Gibson or Helle either - they can help carry your team down the stretch. ANA is healthy and is a great second half team, and WPG seems to be a powerhouse this year with Helle in net.

[j0hn_d0e]

ASAP you should reject that offer. There is nothing to discuss here..in a one way deal like that.

[GSD]

No!

Kucherov >> Voracek

Scheifele > Lee (Although Sheifele is injured)

Erik Karlsson > Klingberg - I know that Klingberg has had the better season to date... but still Karlsson is better.

Heinen < Saad Okay so you win one here... but Saad being better than Heinen does not make up for the difference above.

Gibson < Rinne But I still don't think this makes up for the difference of trading away Kucherov.

agree, except Gibson>Rinne. But still no on trade.

[Belexus75]

Its a 1 year league, thats the thing. And goalies are so valuable. 5 goalie categories and 6 forward categories.. so rinne and helly would be an unstoppable duo. And scheiffle is out another 4-6 weeks

14 teams 1 year league and you have Karlsson, Kuch and shefiele on same team? wow...

[Avalanche_Ambush]

For the love of god NOOOOOO. Don't do it. If your worried about Gibson, don't be...he's a solid goalie on a now healthy team.

[Magicstew]

Is this a keeper league? If it is you loaded for future. - No to the trade

[ddp]

Its mind boggling how one sided this trade is. Why on earth would you consider this?