Trade offer

[Digested Chimichanga Head]

What's everyone think of this offer?

Eberle, Schmaltz, Zibanejad for Simmonds, Carlson

[Axeman33]

You only start 3D and I only see three on your roster. What's your plan for replacing Carlson?

In this setup, is Simmonds a big enough of an upgrade to offset the loss of Carlson. I dont see Zibanejad as an upgrade.

[lucafen4]

You only start 3D and I only see three on your roster. What's your plan for replacing Carlson?

In this setup, is Simmonds a big enough of an upgrade to offset the loss of Carlson. I dont see Zibanejad as an upgrade.

it looks like he would be acquiring Simmonds AND Carlson...

I pass.. in a set up like this Eberle = Simmonds, and Carlson isn't a large enough upgrade on Muzzin to give up Zibs. I pass.

[MasterByte]

If your league doesn't count hits, I would stick with the Z-bad side over Simmonds. He just isn't good enough without counting the peripherals.

On a side note, I love your name hahaha: Digested Chimichanga Head

[Axeman33]

it looks like he would be acquiring Simmonds AND Carlson...

I pass.. in a set up like this Eberle = Simmonds, and Carlson isn't a large enough upgrade on Muzzin to give up Zibs. I pass.

Oops, my bad. Right you are.

Tough one because I do think Carlson is an upgrade to both Jones and Muzzin. I also think that in this setup, I still like Simmonds a little bit more than Eberle. I just think the overall offer isn't quite enough that I would pull the trigger.

If Simmonds >= Eberle, then I dont think I'd deal both Zibanejad AND Schmaltz for Carlson. Close but it's a pass for me too.

- - - Updated - - -

it looks like he would be acquiring Simmonds AND Carlson...

I pass.. in a set up like this Eberle = Simmonds, and Carlson isn't a large enough upgrade on Muzzin to give up Zibs. I pass.

Oops, my bad. Right you are.

Tough one because I do think Carlson is an upgrade to both Jones and Muzzin. I also think that in this setup, I still like Simmonds a little bit more than Eberle. I just think the overall offer isn't quite enough that I would pull the trigger.

If Simmonds >= Eberle, then I dont think I'd deal both Zibanejad AND Schmaltz for Carlson. Close but it's a pass for me too.

[lucafen4]

if you could get him to bump Simmonds to a F with a bit higher offensive ceiling.. then I'd do it. I want a noticeable upgrade on Ebs & Zib though...

[Axeman33]

if you could get him to bump Simmonds to a F with a bit higher offensive ceiling.. then I'd do it. I want a noticeable upgrade on Ebs & Zib though...

Agreed. Considering the original offer is close for me, a little bump on his end would tempt me to say yes. Go back to the other GM and see if he's willing to add something tips it in your favor.