Marchand or Guentzel

[Caporal]

Hey guys!

Tell me if I?m overthinking this one. My team is quite competitive while going through a retooling to get younger : I managed to grab Boeser, Guentzel, Connor and Arvidsson, among others, in the last months. I don?t think I can aim for the title this year (though you never know), but should be ready to fight for it as soon as next year.

Anyway : this fellow GM just decided he want to rebuild, and I have this offer on my table : Guentzel and Elias Lindholm for Marchand and Lucic.

Marchand is obviously the best player now, and he?s not that old, but his supposed concussion is a little worrying, and I wonder to which extent last year was an outlier.

I really like Guentzel, and am not overly worried by his so-so start... but is Marchand too good to pass on?

(Simple scoring system : 2 points a goal, 1 point a pass.)

Thanks for the advice!

[VincentVega]

Marchand's injury is a concussion? All I read about was UBI. Regardless, I still prefer him over Guentzel, easily.

[hockeyrobot]

Marchand over Guentzel for sure.

[Kabonov]

Marchand > Guentzel

B. Marchand, LW Nov 12, 2017 IR Undisclosed injury
You sure it is a concussion?

I would 2nd with Vince. Marchand over Preztel

[Caporal]

Thanks guys. And no, not sure it’s a concussion. Read somewhere it was a suspected concussion, but "undisclosed" is what’s been going round. Anyway, unanimity so far. Still mulling over it.

[Caporal]

Anyone else wants to chime in? Gotta decide tonight...

[Ianclark5525]

Marchand easily

[Caporal]

Thanks guys. Finally, the deal is off the table for now, could be revisited later.