I think it’s a close call, but for your team I think you made out ok with the deal. It’s a big upgrade in net, and you needed that. Losing Ghost hurts, that’s probably the part of the deal I like least. You could argue he was the best player in the deal, but that depends on how Talbot does and if he turns it around. I actually preferred the 2nd deal you posted (Names + Howard) since you would have gotten stronger at G and D and even though you’d have to give up Namestinkov, you had the forward depth to do it.