Which of these guys: Talbot, Lundy, Andersen?

[vonderpibe]

Been offered up a trade by another GM who has tried trading with me to get rid of Lundy. I am not going to accept, However, I think I could counter offer and try buy low on one of his other G (or take on Lundy and upgrade my skaters).

His first offer:

My: Raanta, Foligno
for
His: Wennberg, Lundy

His Next offer:

My: Burns, Nino, Jenner, and Dubnyk
for
His: Steen, Keith, Palat, and Lundy


His goalies are all off to bad starts (Lundy, Talbot, and Andersen) and he is running 1 D short since Schultz is on IR. So I though of offering the following, but would like some input on tweaking it:

My: Dubnyk/Raanta, Faulk, Brassard, Lucic/Dubinksy
for
His: Simmonds/Wheeler, Zibanejad/Monahan, Talbot/Andersen/Lundy

Any Thoughts on this? It's pretty lowball, but if anything it'll send a message to not lowball me in the first place

[hockeyrobot]

His 2nd offer is terrible. Makes no sense. I actually don't mind his first offer. I like Lundy over Raanta.

Your offer is obviously a good one but I doubt he accepts

[MZac]

I'd replace Lundquist with Talbot and resend his first offer. I think your offer will get you no where if you are interested in making a deal. If you just want to send a message then send your offer I suppose.

[HonkyTonkMan]

I'd replace Lundquist with Talbot and resend his first offer. I think your offer will get you no where if you are interested in making a deal. If you just want to send a message then send your offer I suppose.

agree