That's a close call. Neuvirth worries me more than Johnson in terms of backups. Talent wise I would say they are pretty similar - mid range starters with their up and downs. I like Philly more than Buffalo so far this year, so I guess Elliott. But if it were me I would not want to own Elliott without the Neuvirth handcuff right now. If you don't want to use up that extra roster spot then I guess I would stick with Lehner.