Trade Malkin for Schenn?

[Joey7500]

Keep 5 (Malkin, Ovi, Benn, Dubynk, Rask)

offer: schenn c/w and Burns for Malkin, namestinkov c/w and Kesler IR

Should i accept or counter with a player of lesser value that kesler? Namestinkov is really looking valuable as well to give up as he is a winger getting faceoffs and lots of other good stats.

centers: Malkin, Tyler Johnson, Hanzal, Kesler
wingers: namestiknov c/w, foligno c/w, ovi, benn c/w, domi, danault, parise
D: phaneuf, brodie, yandle, provorov, severson
goalies: rask, khbodin, dubynk


Categories:
10 offensive: goals, assists, ppp, shp, gwg, plus/minus, hits, pims, FW, SOG
Goalie: Wins, saves, Save %, GAA, SO
3 centers, 6 wingers, 4D, 4 bench, 2 goalies, 2IR
14 teams

[havanablast21]

This deal has a whole lotta BAD in it for you.

I mean Malkin >> Schenn
and 65% of Malkin>Schenn

So why would you even consider adding to him? And Namestnikov is >/= Pointe argueably.

You will hate yourself if this is what you want in return fir Malkin.

[Grapes]

I own Schenn. If I was offered Malkin for him I would take that deal. Even with the injury concerns.
Hold onto Malkin unless the return is better.
If age is your concern, you may as well move a Ovie too.

[Shift Disturber]

Agree with Havana. You'll give up a lot of offence losing Malkin and don't really need the hits Schenn brings as you already have plenty of that on your team. Point's had a great start but looking at the fancy stats I don't think he can sustain it, and Namestnikov is in a really good spot riding shotgun with Stamkos and Kucherov.

[Joey7500]

He has offered to include burns plus a 5th pick now if I throw in foligno.