Point and bishop vs Klingberg and Gibson ROS

[AlexB13]

head to head league with a categories point system. The categories are as follows:

Forwards-
Goals, assists, +-, PPP, SHP, SOG

Goalies-
Wins, saves, GAA, SV%, SO

[am78]

That's a very tough one. what do you need more? A Dman or C/RW. Bishop will get more wins and put up solid peripherals while Gibson won't get as many wins but better stats IMO. Point won't keep this up but will be a solid 60pt guy and Klingberg could have a 50+ season

[PenguinHunter]

I hope there is points for D men as well

But assuming D scoring is same as forwards...

I would pick Klingberg and Gibson side.

I think Bishop gets more wins than Gibson, but not by many and I think his peripherals will be comparable.

I think Point's point production (That is not what PPP stands for will reduce. And I think having a stud D-man like Klingberg will help more than Point. Value above replacement!

[am78]

I hope there is points for D men as well

But assuming D scoring is same as forwards...

I would pick Klingberg and Gibson side.

I think Bishop gets more wins than Gibson, but not by many and I think his peripherals will be comparable.

I think Point's point production (That is not what PPP stands for will reduce. And I think having a stud D-man like Klingberg will help more than Point. Value above replacement!

I agree, thats the way I was leaning but easier to give better advice once we see his team

[AlexB13]

Thanks for the advice guys, the owner says it?s now or never. I?m just worried about Gibson?s injury issues and it?s a 14 team league so goalies are extremely valuable.. at the same time I am in dire need of defense.. it just worries me with my 2nd and 3rd goalies. And trading for a goalie is nearly impossible in this league


My team is:
Backstrom
Getzlaf
Marchand
Keller
P.Kane
Nylander
Kadri
Shipachyov
Brayden Point
Mantha
Kyle Connor
Ellis(IR)

Hedman
Ekblad
Trouba
*No 4th D*

Elliot
Bishop
Howard

[Sulla]

Looking at your team I’d say you need the d man more unless you have some funky dress rules

[AlexB13]

So what u think guys, should I take it based on my team?

[AlexB13]

???

[Sidenown]

Yes! I actually think Gibson will have pretty much the same stats as Bishop, I think that bishop splits time more than Gibson and that once Anaheim gets healthy they have the better team to ice in front of him. And you need Klingberg more than point, and they may actually give you basically identical pts with point weighted more towards goals but with Kling scoring more on the powerplay. Its not a lopsided win for you but a trade that I think definitely improves your team