Rank these D men. WILL REP

[GSD]

At least three of my four defenseman will probably come from this group. Rank them and why for this year only.

Ghost
Carlson
Klefbom
Schultz
Klingberg
Krug

[Sidenown]

Krug - still underrated in my book
Klingberg - I think he has a bounce back year in him and could end up being the best of this group

Klefbom - I think he takes a step forward and PP will be lethal

Schultz - this group is tough, if letang gets hurt again (likely) he may be the best of all these D, but if not then i have him here
Ghost - High upside but I am not sold on Ghost
Carlson - steady, dependable, but isn't going to blow anyone out of the water stats wise
Note: I have these last three basically the same, Carlson guaranteed production, Ghost has the highest upside, Schultz is the best if letang gets hurt

[GSD]

Krug - still underrated in my book
Klingberg - I think he has a bounce back year in him and could end up being the best of this group

Klefbom - I think he takes a step forward and PP will be lethal

Schultz - this group is tough, if letang gets hurt again (likely) he may be the best of all these D, but if not then i have him here
Ghost - High upside but I am not sold on Ghost
Carlson - steady, dependable, but isn't going to blow anyone out of the water stats wise
Note: I have these last three basically the same, Carlson guaranteed production, Ghost has the highest upside, Schultz is the best if letang gets hurt

The above is almost exactly my thoughts

[GSD]

Any other D men thoughts?

[LordoftheRinks]

What are your scoring cats?

Without knowing your cats, I'm selecting:

Klingberg - really skilled on a team that will score some goals (although Hitch and younger players...)
Krug - generally underrated and generally very productive in most formats
Carlson - I think he bounces back and would be happy with him moving up a notch
Ghost - risk / reward. Again, depending on your stats and if you like to gamble
Klefbom - up and coming but lacking history
Schultz - Letang out = great year (how much you willing to bet on this?)

[cheese_cake]

For points only:
Klingberg : highest and safest upside of the group
Krug: 50 pts can be expected from him again this year, I see him as a 2nd
Carlson / Ghost : down year for both, but there is much more to be expected this year, more risk but still good bets for close to 50pts. Note: contract year for Carlson
Klefbom: probable breakout for him this year as he is bound to be the PP1
Schultz: the one I like the least but only because he needs Letang to be injured to be truly productive.

[suvojitde]

Klingberg
Krug
..
Ghost
Carlson
..
Klefbom
Schultz

Hamilton, Risto, Shattenkirk, Doughty are probably in and around the same ball range (some higher, some lower)

[RizzeeDizzee]

Without factoring in value or where they'd be drafted:

Klingberg
Krug
Klefbom
Ghost
Carlson
Schultz

[StuntMan12]

Klingberg
Krug
Ghost
Carlson
Klefbom
Schultz

[pmorrow]

Klingberg
Krug
Ghost
Klefbom
Carlson
Schultz

[Belexus75]

Klefbom
Klinberg
Krug
Carlson
Schultz
Gost

[Wonko]

For points only:
Klingberg : highest and safest upside of the group
Krug: 50 pts can be expected from him again this year, I see him as a 2nd
Carlson / Ghost : down year for both, but there is much more to be expected this year, more risk but still good bets for close to 50pts. Note: contract year for Carlson
Klefbom: probable breakout for him this year as he is bound to be the PP1
Schultz: the one I like the least but only because he needs Letang to be injured to be truly productive.

Cheese cake says it perfectly for me.

[Drew Parros]

klingberg
klefbom
krug
schultz
ghost
carlson

[skinnypete88]

Krug - still underrated in my book
Klingberg - I think he has a bounce back year in him and could end up being the best of this group

Klefbom - I think he takes a step forward and PP will be lethal

Schultz - this group is tough, if letang gets hurt again (likely) he may be the best of all these D, but if not then i have him here
Ghost - High upside but I am not sold on Ghost
Carlson - steady, dependable, but isn't going to blow anyone out of the water stats wise
Note: I have these last three basically the same, Carlson guaranteed production, Ghost has the highest upside, Schultz is the best if letang gets hurt

This. With SOG as a cat I'd put Ghost at the top of these three slightly but agree they're all the same