Rank these young D please

[Spinorama514]

Based off some conversations I've been having with some other GM's in my pool, some of these guys may be gone by the time my pick comes around (17th overall), but I'd love to know how you'd rank these guys, in terms of who you would pick first (league details in my sig):

- Charlie McAvoy
- Brandon Montour
- Julius Honka
- Josh Morrissey
- Troy Stecher
- Connor Murphy
- Thomas Chabot
- Travis Sanheim
- Mickael Sergachev
- Will Butcher
- Phillippe Myers

Thanks for the help.

[cheese_cake]

McAvoy and Montour are ahead of this group skillwise, but also because their arrival is imminent for both and people target them. Chances are they'll be gone by the time you pick.

Chabot, Honka, Sergachev, Butcher are all young D with potentiel for this season and mostly the next one. I like Chabot and Sergachev, but the Butcher might have the most impact this year depending on where he signs (but I don't like him nearly as much compared to the three others in terms of upside). I think I would personnally rank them Sergachev > Chabot > Butcher > Honka.

Morrissey, Stetcher, and Myers are all great young D, but I'm afraid I dont have the knowledge on their respective upside relative to the other players you list nor do I know when will they be ready, so I unfortunately can't help.

Sanheim I know I would probably put last for the only reason that he is burried way deep in Phili, Provorov Ghost and so forth should produce most of the points from the D there for the coming years + isn't ready until next year at least.

Hope I was of any help, unfortunately I don't have knowledge for all of them

[jdreed3184]

In a points only league, not considering ETA:

Montour
McAvoy

Chabot
Honka

Sergachev
Butcher
Morrissey
Sanheim

Murphy
Stecher
Myers

Something like that....

[Avalanche_Ambush]

- Montour
- McAvoy/Chabot
- Honka
- Sergachev
- Morrissey
- Sanheim (would prob move up a spot or 2 if wasn't in a log jam with philly or gets traded)
- The rest