Schiefle panarin vs Eichle W.nylander

[Slickricks]

Our last frenzy of trades are starting to happen and I only received one I need opinions on. I am a competitive team and should for awhile with my roster but I was offered as the title says My Schiefle and panarin for his Eichle and W.Nylander. is this enough of an upgrade to warrant the move or is it lateral?

[Axeman33]

I'd do that deal.

While it may not look it yet, I think Eichel is the best player in this deal. I'd have him over everyone in this deal. Willie isn't Panarin yet, but could very well be just as good, if not better in the next season or two.

Short term, it may look like you lose this deal on the score sheet but that won't be too long before that changes.

[newper114]

Agree will lose a bit this year but I'd take the deal.

Eichel has room to improve while inthink the guys your giving up hit their highs

[cheese_cake]

You are trading players of high upside for younger versions. I agree on Eichel having probably the highest upside, but while I think Nylander is a promising young player, Panarin and Scheifele are themselves really good fantasy contributors already. I'm not sure I would do this deal, you trade for potential by sending two proven assets..

My concern is Nylander maybe not producing at Panarin's pace for the next two years. If it was ensured, I think I would like the deal for you. Depends if you're okay with that risk.

[Hunter9]

Agree this is a close deal, with Scheif and Panarin being a bit safer.

But I think I take the Eichel/Nylander side. If Eichel becomes what most people expect, this deal would no longer be possible.

[Slickricks]

Yeah I thought the risk was there forsure. Only thing I have I'd possibly think could work is swapping panarin for monohan on my end. Since monohan and nylamder may be more even right from this year. I do realize the risk so That's why I was hesitant and wanted some opinions

[rookien]

If you are gonna fight for the title this year then keep Scheifele and Panarin. Theres a reason he send the offer he wants proven studs compared to potentiel bigger studs. But they are all fine players though..

[RizzeeDizzee]

Good deal. You win big in the future and it will be almost a wash for this year. I think you owe it to yourself to take it.

[SergeP]

I would jump on this deal too. I think Panarin will take a bit of a step back this year without Kane. It could just be a smallish step back but I wouldn't be shocked if it was more than that. Scheifele is a great player but again, I'd bet on Eichel to outpoint him this year and moving forward.

[Triplea14]

I'd take that deal. Best player in eichel and highest upside in Nylander. Having said that I don't think there is any drop off for panarin on Columbus. Better pp and higher scoring it's just spread out more. But I still do the trade and I def sub monahan in if that's possible

[Belexus75]

to me its win now and in the future, i think Schefiele will regress slightly and i also think Panarin will find it hard to produce at same pace in CBJ. If Eichel plays full season he will hit 80+ and Nylander has good chance at 65-70. So short term its a was at worst and long term its big win.

[hockeymanG23]

Go for it!

[finnys_fanatsy]

Eichel and Willy Nilly for me. both are ripe for huge success....