We don't know how many starters you have per night or week.
We also don't know if you are in win now, rebuilding or somewhere in between.
We also don't know the rest of your roster.
All that said, for a win now time, I like deal 1 and am not crazy about deal 2. There is no trophy or prize for having younger players. Unless you were deep in D, or really light on the wing, or are rebuilding, I would have kept Burns.