With the additional information, I'm tempted to keep Anderson. Often, goaltending isn't as crucial in H2H leagues where the ratio favours skaters, but given the options and your current group, I'd rather solidify your top two, especially in a 14 team league. I feel that need is greater than keeping another skater and having to hope to get a decent #2 goalie. What is the minimum number of goalie appearances per week? How did you manage your goaltending last year - what level of importance?

On the flip side, those are solid skaters, and Hornqvist especially helps with a bit more across the board production but I'm guessing they won't be available when it's your turn to draft. If you kept Anderson, what skaters do you foresee being available in the early part of the draft?