Hedman or Hamilton?

[TheBends]

Hey,

I'm looking to shave some cap and was thinking of possibly offering Hedman for Hamilton.

Thoughts?
My other Defenders are Risto, Klingberg, Gudas, Nurse and McNabb

[Eskimo Brother]

That's a pretty solid idea for the price. Hedman also usually misses a few more games.
Stone and Hamonic just got brought in too and they can handle a lot more of the defensive minutes.

[Sulla]

I'm a huge Hamilton fan and have raised my flag re Hedman and his pp production with Stamkos returning so to save that sort of money makes it a no brainier for me

[RizzeeDizzee]

From where I sit, you would be making a good trade, although you should be able to get a sweetener added - that is, you should be able to get another asset back from the player who'll be receiving Hedman.

[Axeman33]

I prefer Hedman to Hamiliton but in a cap league, this makes sense.

[Call of Doughty]

With your cats, it's pretty split down the middle with these two. If Heds is going to recede in points (ppp) as other's have mentioned, then this is a good deal for you. I too would ask for an extra piece coming your way or a swap in picks etc.

[tobias]

This is a good trade to make to shave cap space.

[MasterByte]

Go for it, looks like a great idea for your setup.
If this was not a cap league though Hedman would still be the better choice.

[FinnishFlash]

I like Hedman more than Hamilton, but in a cap league I'd prefer Dougie.

[Wonko]

I prefer Hedman apples to apples but to shave off that cap space this looks to be an advantageous move for you. Like others have said, no harm in asking for a little sweetener on top, especially with Hedman's stellar performance last season.

[TheBends]

Thanks for the feedback, everyone but he turned down the offer. I'll have to shave cap elsewhere haha