How would you rank these Dmen using these Cats.?

[IronCityCap87]

G, A, +/-, PIM, PPP, SHP, ATOI, HIT, BLK, DEF

Justin Faulk
Colton Parayko
Jacob Trouba
Oscar Klefbom
John Carlson
Tyson Barrie
Torey Krug

[LuigiC173]

Justin Faulk
Jacob Trouba
John Carlson
Tory Krug
Tyson Barrie
Oscar Klefbom
Colton Parayko

[lucafen4]

Justin Faulk
Jacob Trouba
Torey Krug
John Carlson
Oscar Klefbom
Tyson Barrie
Colton Parayko

[Pengwin7]

They're pretty close.

For me:

1a Klefbom
1b Carlson
1c Trouba
1d Parayko
...
2a Krug
2b Faulk
2c Barrie

IMO, Justin Faulk is quite overrated.
You don't count SOG... and outside of his 49pt season, he's more of a 40pt-pacing D-man who misses a handful of games.
And he's yet to show he can have a PLUS season, -19, -22, -18.
People too often, IMO, just disregard +/- because it does vary for some players.
And, I think, Faulk gets too much love for barely scraping a tad over 100 hits. Meh.

Faulk (like Barrie) is on a bad team and they're poor defensive D-men and they'll stay MINUS D-men.
That's hard to compensate for... and its a real MINUS in the fantasy world.
I'd prefer a few less HIT/BLK if I'm getting a PLUS D-man like I expect from Carlson, Parayko, and Klefbom.
Trouba has good all around numbers and I think his game is about to pop, so I included him in upper tier.

I like Krug's offense... but that's it. No peripherals.

[Bass56]

Justin Faulk (top mix of potential and fills up all cats)
John Carlson (down year last year, should bounce back pts-wise but not a top hitter)
Colton Parayko (should continue to improve, good across the board)
Jacob Trouba (good multi-cat guy, could rise up here but I would need to see him repeat last year's limited-but-great output before)
Torey Krug (less hits, less points, no SOG counted)
Oscar Klefbom (he's a good young D in a great situation; the only reason he's at the bottom of my list is because I feel the others are a notch above)
Tyson Barrie (great point-getter but lack of hits and horrible +/- chances will bring down his value)

[FinnishFlash]

They're pretty close.

For me:

1a Klefbom
1b Carlson
1c Trouba
1d Parayko
...
2a Krug
2b Faulk
2c Barrie

IMO, Justin Faulk is quite overrated.
You don't count SOG... and outside of his 49pt season, he's more of a 40pt-pacing D-man who misses a handful of games.
And he's yet to show he can have a PLUS season, -19, -22, -18.
People too often, IMO, just disregard +/- because it does vary for some players.
And, I think, Faulk gets too much love for barely scraping a tad over 100 hits. Meh.

Faulk (like Barrie) is on a bad team and they're poor defensive D-men and they'll stay MINUS D-men.
That's hard to compensate for... and its a real MINUS in the fantasy world.
I'd prefer a few less HIT/BLK if I'm getting a PLUS D-man like I expect from Carlson, Parayko, and Klefbom.
Trouba has good all around numbers and I think his game is about to pop, so I included him in upper tier.

I like Krug's offense... but that's it. No peripherals.

This is an excellent response.