Rank these young Dmen!

[PPQB]

Trying to finalize my draft list for Saturday. Its a keeper league with points only.....In which order would you target these guys?? i don't know much about this years dmen drafted so any help will help!!

Makar
Butcher
Heiskanen
P. Myers(PHI)
Saarijarvi
Girard
Walman
Schmaltz(STL)
Vaakanainen
McAvoy
Joseph(ARI)
Slavin
Bowey
Valimaki
Guhle
Liljegren
Brannstrom

[randomscrub23]

Well... My knowledge on D prospects isn't too deep bit I will say:

1) The obvious - Makar is the most boom/bust but years away either way.

2) My top 3 would probably be:

McAvoy
Liljegren
Heisaken

What about Theodore, Chabot, and Montour? Are they all already drafted?

[StuntMan12]

McAvoy
Slavin
Makar
Heiskanen
P. Myers(PHI)
Schmaltz(STL)
Liljegren
Bowey
Brannstrom
Butcher
Walman
Vaakanainen
Saarijarvi
Girard
Guhle
Valimaki
Joseph(ARI)

[finnys_fanatsy]

McAvoy tops the list..by a good margin.

Then it's Slavin Makar and Liljegren in any order for me.

[PPQB]

Theodore, Montour, Chabot are taken. That list are the dmen left for my draft this weekend.


I forgot to add Skjei in there.

[Jouko-Pouko]

My list includes combination of risk and upside, so it's not purely based on upside like some may have. For points-only league, my list would be:

McAvoy
Makar
Brannstrom
Liljegren
Heiskanen
P.Myers
Slavin
Valimaki
Walman
Butcher
J.Schmaltz
Girard
Saarijarvi
Guhle
Bowey
Vaakanainen
P.Joseph