New Jersey vs Philadelphia goalies

[sdee]

Who would you rather have for wins?
Cory Schnieder who seems to have played his worst season in 2016/2017 (Kinkaid seemed to play better) or
Brian Elliot who is new in Philly but in a tandem with Neuvy.

[jdreed3184]

Schneider all day long. He's an elite goalie on a bad team. But that bad team is improving IMO.

Elliott will play 45 games and win 25 of them. I expect Schneider to play 65+ games and win 30-35 of them.

[newper114]

Devils for sure. Defense isn't all that great still but the offense will for sure improve over last year.

[StuntMan12]

still go with schneider. had an off year, should rebound a bit, might not be a top 5 goalie in the league but do expect better numbers all around.

[sdee]

I don't know...thinking Elliot still...Schnieder hasn't won't more than 27 games in a season for the Devils.
Schneider
======
60 gp and 20 wins with .908

Elliot who had a bad year won
===================
49 gp and 26 wins with .910

I think if Kovalchuk signs and stays in NJ I would stay with Schneider.

I am somewhat 60 - 40 with Elliot. Still got a couple of months for keeper submission.

[jdreed3184]

Is this a keeper?

Elliott has never had a 30 win season either and his last three seasons of 25ish wins was behind a really good Blues team and a Flames team that went nutty for 20 games. Schneider is steady.

If this is a keeper, I'd say Schneider averages 32 wins over the next 3 years to Elliott's 25. If this is a one-year, then the stakes are much lower and betting on Elliott has a lower downside.

[MrSandals]

New Jersey should be a touch better and Schneider is going to get massive starts. Definitely Schneider. I don't trust Elliott.

[Eskimo Brother]

Schneider for me as well. Always go with the starter over the tandem when possible.

[Axeman33]

I agree with the majority that Schneider is the better option. I think NJ still has another deal or two up their sleeves to try and improve their backend. Their forward corps are already improved over last year.