Betts for Gold

[oilspill23]

Got offered Goldschmidt and Hwan Oh for Betts and Upton.

Id be able to put Goldy at 1B and move Myers to OF...

I like this, a lot, as i have Pollock and Cespedes coming of DL soon.


Take this deal?

[hockeyrobot]

Got offered Goldschmidt and Hwan Oh for Betts and Upton.

Id be able to put Goldy at 1B and move Myers to OF...

I like this, a lot, as i have Pollock and Cespedes coming of DL soon.


Take this deal?

I would probably take it....just beware of two things. Don't think Goldie's SB will maintain. And be prepared for an absolutely blistering month or two from Upton at some point.

If you're ok with those then yes I'd take it.

[Eskimo Brother]

I would probably take it....just beware of two things. Don't think Goldie's SB will maintain. And be prepared for an absolutely blistering month or two from Upton at some point.

If you're ok with those then yes I'd take it.

Agree with HR. The positional upgrades should work for you and your DL guys help mitigate the OF losses. Which pitcher would you then be dropping?

[oilspill23]

Agree with HR. The positional upgrades should work for you and your DL guys help mitigate the OF losses. Which pitcher would you then be dropping?

Once they're all back from DL, I'll have to decide between a few.. G. Gonzalez, Miller, maybe Hosmer...

I also might be adding Judge if I can get my other deal through. But having a hard time parting with Kipnis/Cargo to get it done.

[seguingenesis]

I don't think I would, I'd rather have Betts than Goldy (despite his unreal start) and you don't even have saves as a category so why trade for Oh?

[oilspill23]

Whoops, Saves is supposed to be a part of my signature. They do count in our league.

I'm intrigued by the offer because 1B is harder to find than OF, and I have a shit ton of OF's that are good.

Also, what are your thoughts on Judge ROS

[seguingenesis]

Even w/ saves, I'm a fellow Oh owner and I'm not completely convinced he'll be closing by H2H playoffs time (Rosenthal has looked real good at times, and closers change so often) so usually I prefer trading for better hitters at the cost of a closer unless I'm desperate for saves.

If you need HR def like Judge ROS - his BABIP is .385 so expect some regression but great hitters park and clearly talented. I'd def be okay with parting for a guy like Kipnis for him.

[seguingenesis]

If you're getting Oh I would try to sell high on Glover or sell high on Berrios for an SP upgrade with Betts for Goldy

[oilspill23]

I don't even care about Oh in this deal. I have a lot of good closers as it stands. I know Betts/Upton for Goldy is a bit of an overpayment, but positionally I like it for my team.

The other offer is currently Kipnis/Cargo for Judge/A. Sanchez. He's mulling it over, but I might need to something to push him to do it.

[hockeyrobot]

I don't even care about Oh in this deal. I have a lot of good closers as it stands. I know Betts/Upton for Goldy is a bit of an overpayment, but positionally I like it for my team.

The other offer is currently Kipnis/Cargo for Judge/A. Sanchez. He's mulling it over, but I might need to something to push him to do it.

I would wait it out. You;re giving a lot right now.

[oilspill23]

I would wait it out. You;re giving a lot right now.

In which deal?