Pick a side

[MarnerMania]

Dynasty - G/A/PTS/PIM/SOG/BLK/HIT/FOW

Been trying to get Sid all year with no luck. Had a rough season, but I'm going all in for next year.

[Mr. Guru]

I'll take the Sid side?

[hockeyrobot]

I'll take the Sid side?

Sid side is always better even when you don't know who is involved.

[MarnerMania]

Ooops, didn't hit the poll. It's there now

[Mr. Guru]

Which Johnson

[Bass56]

Sid side is always better even when you don't know who is involved.

+1 for this

Which Johnson

Doesn't matter... Comment above prevails

Jokes aside, I'm pretty sure it's Tyler

[Mr. Guru]

Yeah. Crosby side does win, still.

[MZac]

I voted Seguin side. In a limited keeper I take Crosby but in dynasty I think it's too much depth to give up personally.

Main reasons for me is Crosby's injury risk (I don't think he's anywhere near slowing down when he's playing but don't forget the beginning of the season).

Age difference between the two sides.

I'd argue that next year's production:

Seguin and Kuznetsov > Crosby and Johnson (I'll admit this could go either way but it's close enough to have age and Leddy swing it for me)

[Nehithaw]

I've always been curious to know if Tyler Seguin can succeed (as well as he has) playing with players like Guentzel and Sheary. Does anyone know how his stats look when he is without Benn?

I ask this because I was once chastised by some guys who thought they knew more for trading Seguin to acquire Crosby (it was a package deal).

I know Crosby is Crosby on his own, Do others make Seguin who he is?

[PenguinHunter]

I prefer the Seguin/Kuznetsov side. These two guys are young and I think they will both have great years next year. I am not a fan of Johnson. and as mentioned above, having the younger Leddy over Keith is a great upgrade.

Kuznetsov (24) and Seguin (25) are both just entering into the prime ages of their careers. Oh yeah, and Leddy is 26 years old.

[Axeman33]

What's your team situation? Are you close to winning or still trying to build something up?

If you are close to winning, I'll take the Sid side. If you don't think this deal puts you near the win, then keep what you have.

[havanablast21]

Crosby/Keith/Johnson side wins for me.

[finnys_fanatsy]

as much as Sid is teh man, teh Seguin / Kuz side wins this one.

Kieth and TJ just cant match

[MarnerMania]

Offered the deal, immediately dismissed. Manager doesn't want Leddy and wants to work Nylander into the trade. Not sure I can make that work.

thanks everyone

[Nehithaw]

If you leave Keith out of the deal it would look more appealing. It's no use playing around with Keith and Leddy and focus on who you really want. It's better for you to receive less and give less, compared to giving up Nylander. If he insists on including Nylander, let him know that Kuznetsov is no longer a part of the deal - one or the other, not both.

Seguin and Kuznetsov is an excellent start towards acquiring Sid - remind your trading partner that the guys you are offering are among the best young players in the game. As you can see by the results there are many here that believe they are worth more than what you'd be getting back.