Bishop/stamkos for mackinnon/mantha

[Mcdangles]

Keeper league currently in first and could use the depth for the playoffs. Bishop is not a starter for me. Same stats as sig different league. hurts a little to trade stamkos but is the return worth it?

[MZac]

This is a no for me. Keep bishop and stammer.

[mynameistickle]

Yeah this is a no for me also. Not even close really. I value both Bishop and Stamkos well ahead of MacKinnon for fantasy purposes

[Jager's Mullet]

Hit no as fast as u can and clear this trade from ur memory

[Pit Bulls]

Noooooooooooo! Don't do it!!!!!!!!!

[Triplea14]

You're giving up the 2 best players in the deal. That never works

[kkooopitar]

stay put

[Sulla]

I even less likely to move him as I think the Bolts roll Bishop the next little while which should see an uptick in valie

[havanablast21]

You'd be fine I giving away 2 elite talents for pennies on the dollar.
Not a chance. 1 year, maybe. Keeper? Reckless Decision IMO.

- - - Updated - - -

You'd be fine I giving away 2 elite talents for pennies on the dollar.
Not a chance. 1 year, maybe. Keeper? Reckless Decision IMO.

[Mcdangles]

Okay, thank you for responses. I rejected the offer, but he quickly sent just mackinnon for bishop feel like that doesn't change anything?

[lucafen4]

I traded Stamkos to boost my playoff run, I got Carter & Wheeler in return.

Mack - Bishop is a lot better & closer but, do you start 2 goalies or one? Because, while you have several on your roster, Bishop is easily your #2 G - then it drops to Markstrom. I'm not sure you have the goalie depth to move Bishop.

That said, I would reject and stand pat - especially if Bishop gets moved to a team like Calgary in the next week, becoming the starter.

- - - Updated - - -

I traded Stamkos to boost my playoff run, I got Carter & Wheeler in return.

Mack - Bishop is a lot better & closer but, do you start 2 goalies or one? Because, while you have several on your roster, Bishop is easily your #2 G - then it drops to Markstrom. I'm not sure you have the goalie depth to move Bishop.

That said, I would reject and stand pat - especially if Bishop gets moved to a team like Calgary in the next week, becoming the starter.

[Mcdangles]

My tenders are pekka and bob, with their backups. Bishop doesn't get many starts on my team.

[finnys_fanatsy]

yes to Mack / Bishop.

[Mcdangles]

So in a turn of events another GM has got involved in the offers for bishop. He has offered two first rounds one this year which is actually mine that I traded earlier in the year probably be 10-12 pick and his first next year which should be top 7. that said tho I'm like the Mack for bishop still as I hope he will return to the player he once was he is still very young. Question is do I accept or do I use the other gm's offer and try to squeeze more outta Mack offer?

[finnys_fanatsy]

Those two picks are not even close to being equal to Mack and likely don't have enough pull to sway the Mack owner to pony up..it wouldn't for me anyway. You can try but I wouldn't push it too hard.