Comparing W. Nylander, Rantanen and Dvorak

[pier_hockey]

Point projections for these 3 next year and their ceiling. Thanks. Will repity rep rep.

[Sulla]

Rantanen for me... Nylander a close second and Dvorak a little behind them both. Everyone loves the leafs and though I believe in Babcock to do everything he can in his coaching Arsenal to avoid the sophomore slump (especially as everyone on Toronto will also expect more) im not sure they will come out of that pressure cooker unharmed next season

- - - Updated - - -

Rantanen for me... Nylander a close second and Dvorak a little behind them both. Everyone loves the leafs and though I believe in Babcock to do everything he can in his coaching Arsenal to avoid the sophomore slump (especially as everyone on Toronto will also expect more) im not sure they will come out of that pressure cooker unharmed next season

[Axeman33]

Points only, I prefer Nylander more than the other two. Rantanen would be my second choice and then Dvorak.

[lucafen4]

I've got them

Nylander
Rantanen
Dvorak

I think in 3yrs we're talking about three players that could potentially flip-flop point totals. But for most seasons, this is how I've got it, but they're close. I think Dvorak will be closer to these two than people will rank him in 3yrs time.

[Canucks_fan18]

Ranking Dvorak third is the easy choice right now because he just simply does not have the track the other two have at the moment. I guess with young talent you would rather have a bird in hand then two in the bush. I would rather make predictions on production already in the NHL, then wait for a potential breakout that might never happen. So in this case I am going Nylander, Ratty then Dvorak. But that's only based on if I had to pick at this very moment. This could be very fluent over the next three years.

[StuntMan12]

Nylander
Rantanen

Dvorak

- - - Updated - - -

Nylander
Rantanen

Dvorak

[Jouko-Pouko]

I see Nylander with 70+ point upside, so I rank him first. I think Rantanen settles more in that 60-70 point range, and I would have him ranked 2nd. Dvorak could also get into that 60-70 point range or he could be more in the 55-65 point range but anyways I would rank him 3rd.

[Mr. Guru]

Rantanen and Nylander are a coin flip.

Dvor?k a step below

- - - Updated - - -

Rantanen and Nylander are a coin flip.

Dvor?k a step below

[StuntMan12]

is buchnevich in the same category as Nylander or Rantanen? above? below?

[Jouko-Pouko]

is buchnevich in the same category as Nylander or Rantanen? above? below?

Probably in the same tier with Dvorak I think.

[agentzero]

Nylander, Dvorak, Rantanen. Pts only, Pts only, multicat. Dvorak is turning in a pretty darn good rookie season on a terrible team. I think he will be excellent competition to Strome for the long-term #1C option in ARZ. I think he might actually be the better player of the two in the pros. Strome might be a while.