My Rinne and Hoffman for Martin Jones. Thoughts?

[RunningRob]

New thread because it's a revised offer. Countered with Hoffman instead of Backes because he wants someone with more scoring potential.

Original Offer:

My: For:
Pekka Rinne Martin Jones
David Backes

Counter Offer:

My For:
Pekka Rinne Martin Jones
Mike Hoffman


His Current Roster:

C: Malkin, Matthews, Backlund, Coyle
LW: Ovechkin, Voracek, Granlund
RW: Atkinson, Hornqvist, Pastrnak
D: Karlsson, Hamilton, Giordano, Gudas (would drop)
G: Jones, Lunqvist, Budaj
IR: Barkov

[Eskimo Brother]

Your offers aren't spaced well so they're tough to read. Because of the title I get it though.
I would make either deal. Jones is enough of an upgrade.

- - - Updated - - -

Your offers aren't spaced well so they're tough to read. Because of the title I get it though.
I would make either deal. Jones is enough of an upgrade.

[RunningRob]

Sorry, I'm receiving M. Jones and sending away Rinne and Hoffman.

Hate to give up Hoffman as he's been on a tear but I think Rinne is done as an elite tender and Nashville has been up and down this year. Plus, Saros is doing quite well (despite almost blowing that game tonight). Rinne seems like an injury risk waiting to happen, come to think of it, it's about time it seems.

Just seeking final input before confirmation.

- - - Updated - - -

Sorry, I'm receiving M. Jones and sending away Rinne and Hoffman.

Hate to give up Hoffman as he's been on a tear but I think Rinne is done as an elite tender and Nashville has been up and down this year. Plus, Saros is doing quite well (despite almost blowing that game tonight). Rinne seems like an injury risk waiting to happen, come to think of it, it's about time it seems.

Just seeking final input before confirmation.

[Sulla]

What's the point values of shots and goals against?

[RunningRob]

We don't count SOG and Goals Against are -1.

Any other thoughts guys?

- - - Updated - - -

We don't count SOG and Goals Against are -1.

Any other thoughts guys?

[RunningRob]

Any other thoughts?

Tempted to take it. Forward depth on the wire helps.

- - - Updated - - -

Any other thoughts?

Tempted to take it. Forward depth on the wire helps.

[davemoosehead]

Who will be replacing Hoffman?

This looks like a pretty easy yes for me.

- - - Updated - - -

Who will be replacing Hoffman?

This looks like a pretty easy yes for me.

[RunningRob]

Notable replacements for Hoffman are the following:

Okposo
Duchene
ROR
Monahan
Landeskog
Marner
Neal

D
Faulk
Barrie

[Moses]

yes yes and yes... make the deal and grab a W off of the WW

[RunningRob]

Just accepted it. Who would you grab?

- - - Updated - - -

Just accepted it. Who would you grab?

[Moses]

Looking at your team I would want another winger as you have the C position covered. I'd be looking at Landeskog or Neal and hoping for a big second half.

[RunningRob]

What about Duchene's RW/C dual eligibility? I really like Okposo too.

[stevegamer]

I'd pick up a defenseman, and it might even be the dropped Gudas over Faulk, depending on how he stacks up.

[RunningRob]

Interesting pick with Gudas. Care to elaborate?

I see it both ways. I'd like another winger and Okposo/Marner are very tempting but Justin Faulk is considerable irreplacable around these parts given his high sog and favorable playoff schedule, among other things.

- - - Updated - - -

Interesting pick with Gudas. Care to elaborate?

I see it both ways. I'd like another winger and Okposo/Marner are very tempting but Justin Faulk is considerable irreplacable around these parts given his high sog and favorable playoff schedule, among other things.

[stevegamer]

You have PIM, Hits, and Blocks. Gudas does those things. He's probably top 20-ish in all 3, and he's been banged up & already suspended this year, so he's missed some time. When it gets down to division game, things will get feistier, and the #1 penalized team most years is wearing black & orange.

Faulk's shots generate no points in your format, as far as I see from your sig.

I know nothing about playoff schedules, as my league doesn't work close to the same way anyone else's does.