MacKinnon vs Saad vs Marner vs Coyle

[stevetronix]

For a one year league points only (positions don't matter), who do you guys like better for the rest of the season?

[4T2]

All 4 of these guys are producing around the same clip and each team has about the same number of games remaining. With that in mind I go with Mack here as he is the most proven of the bunch. He's been having a "down" year whereas guys like Coyle and Marner are exceeding expectations. Saad is the wild card here, but I feel he is the least likely of the 4 to end up producing the most.

[lucafen4]

I take Marner the highest offensive pedigree of the bunch. Mack playing for Colorado sends up too many red flags in your format. Saad's on a great pace, but I expect regression in the 2nd half. Coyle's an interesting one, he's been a slow build as a player, Minn doesn't appear to be slowing down. He'd be my second choice.

Marner, has a different level of offensive ability though, he's shown it time and time again, he can just take over the entire offensive zone and pick it a part with his precision passing, or wrist shot. It's a hunch, but Marner's a gamer. As the games get more meaningful in the 2nd half and the Leafs start digging in for a playoff run, I expect his pt/gm to increase.

- - - Updated - - -

I take Marner the highest offensive pedigree of the bunch. Mack playing for Colorado sends up too many red flags in your format. Saad's on a great pace, but I expect regression in the 2nd half. Coyle's an interesting one, he's been a slow build as a player, Minn doesn't appear to be slowing down. He'd be my second choice.

Marner, has a different level of offensive ability though, he's shown it time and time again, he can just take over the entire offensive zone and pick it a part with his precision passing, or wrist shot. It's a hunch, but Marner's a gamer. As the games get more meaningful in the 2nd half and the Leafs start digging in for a playoff run, I expect his pt/gm to increase.

[Eskimo Brother]

Marner by a hair just because Colorado is a tire fire right now.
MacKinnon is next, then Coyle then Saad.

- - - Updated - - -

Marner by a hair just because Colorado is a tire fire right now.
MacKinnon is next, then Coyle then Saad.

[jeff416]

Coyle last

[stevetronix]

Thanks for weighing in guys. Someone just dropped Radulov to make things even more interesting.

[Sulla]

Radulov and then Mak for me... Mak primarily because he's matching these guys whilst being part of the tyre fire.. If the Avs show any uptick he will be driving it (it's a big if right now though)

[Tobias Funke]

Grab Radulov. Should heat up again with Galchenyuk back. Three PPP last night.

[stevetronix]

Done. Good feedback, appreciate it guys.