Do i accept this ovechkin/byfuglien/frolik for seguin/barrie/tatar

[gregster75]

I currently have the Seguin half of the deal he's also thrown in his 3rd round for my 15th round. Im sitting in second place 70 points behind the leader. It's a points only league with a bonus of .5 for PPP. Keep 15 players.

[Sidenown]

I don't think I would do this deal. You already have a solid defence even though Big Buff would look nice in there with Klingberg et al. I actually think in a points only keeper that Seguin >> Ovie, based on age and the fact that while Ovie likely gets more goals I would bet on Seguin to outpoint Ovie each year going forward. Also, while Buff is a beast in multi cat leagues, he is actually pretty comparable to Barrie in points only and 6 years older so I think those two are a push. I don't think Frolik and Tatar really make a difference, but I would say that Tatar might have a slightly higher upside but Frolik is having the better year so far.

- - - Updated - - -

I don't think I would do this deal. You already have a solid defence even though Big Buff would look nice in there with Klingberg et al. I actually think in a points only keeper that Seguin >> Ovie, based on age and the fact that while Ovie likely gets more goals I would bet on Seguin to outpoint Ovie each year going forward. Also, while Buff is a beast in multi cat leagues, he is actually pretty comparable to Barrie in points only and 6 years older so I think those two are a push. I don't think Frolik and Tatar really make a difference, but I would say that Tatar might have a slightly higher upside but Frolik is having the better year so far.

[lucafen4]

This trade isn't going to allow you to close the gap on 1sts, you'll lose on Seguin 80+ to 70-75... Ina pts only... the rest is a wash IMO.

[Vanity686]

I prefer the Seguin side longterm. The pp points make it interesting

[gregster75]

Thank you all for your responses...ill figure out how to give the rep and hand som eout...lol