What scoring format do you prefer for goalies ?

[Grapes]

Our 1 year league will become a limited keeper. Point based scoring. I received some great input from the forums regarding Forward/Dmen scoring categories and weighting.

I'm having trouble coming up with goalie categories and appropriate weighting for each stat.
Considered W(3), Saves(.5), GA(-1), S/O(3), OTL(1)

The problem I'm having is with the goalie scoring values.
Minnesoata beats Colorado 2-1.
Dubnyk makes 18 saves, plus the win, 3pts win, -.5 GA, +3.6 saves = 6.1 pts
Vary makes 40 saves in the loss, -1 GA, +8 saves = 7 pts
Doesn't make sense to me that the winning goalie gets less points ?

Would appreciate knowing your goalie categories and points for each stat. Whether you like it or what would you change.
I'd like to come up with 4-5 scoring categories if possible. Not really a fan of -minus for goals against.

All input greatly appreciated, cheers

[Dobber]

You mean 0.2 for saves?

I use w+0.5*OTL-1L-.25*GA+0.05SV+2SO+A


Works very well, comparable to players (though in recent defensive era, goalies are starting to creep up a bit)

- - - Updated - - -

You mean 0.2 for saves?

I use w+0.5*OTL-1L-.25*GA+0.05SV+2SO+A


Works very well, comparable to players (though in recent defensive era, goalies are starting to creep up a bit)

[Grapes]

From my forum and daily rambling reading you are involved in a Points only keeper where the points move with the player.
Would you be so kind as to provide me with those settings. Slainte mhaith

- - - Updated - - -

From my forum and daily rambling reading you are involved in a Points only keeper where the points move with the player.
Would you be so kind as to provide me with those settings. Slainte mhaith

[Grapes]

I have run various numbers through FHG.
Seems W(2), OTL(1), SO(1), SV(.1)
G(3), A(2), PPP(1), Sog(.1), Hits(.1), Blks(.1) works not too bad.

- - - Updated - - -

I have run various numbers through FHG.
Seems W(2), OTL(1), SO(1), SV(.1)
G(3), A(2), PPP(1), Sog(.1), Hits(.1), Blks(.1) works not too bad.

[pmorrow]

I use w+0.5*OTL-1L-.25*GA+0.05SV+2SO+A

*types into TI-83*

[pmorrow]

For what it's worth, my points only league on Fantrax used this and most liked it:

W - 3
GA - -0.3
SV - 0.1
SO - 1
OTL - 1

I don't know why but it usually seemed to reflect a goalie's performance