Hellebuyck vs Mrazek

[finminer]

League in sig. I've been working with one owner where the centerpiece of the trade is Hellebuyck. I won't trade him without getting a goalie back, Mrazek is the best he has. I originally traded Mrazek to him, but my team has changed considerably and I am not contending. I see the two as similar - both on poor defensive teams, talented but having trouble showing it when getting shelled regularly. I can probably get a premium since he wants Helly badly.

Who do you like better over the next three years, Mrazek or Hellebuyck? Your reasoning?

Thanks as always.

[rufio.85]

Both haven't proven they can fully handle #1 duties yet, but I'll take Hellebuyck even if Mrazek is probably as talented if not more.
Hellboy has a much better team in front of him and I don't like where Detroit is heading...

Unless you can get a significant piece along with Mrazek, I'd stand pat.
Is there any other piece to the equation we should know about?

- - - Updated - - -

Both haven't proven they can fully handle #1 duties yet, but I'll take Hellebuyck even if Mrazek is probably as talented if not more.
Hellboy has a much better team in front of him and I don't like where Detroit is heading...

Unless you can get a significant piece along with Mrazek, I'd stand pat.
Is there any other piece to the equation we should know about?

[hockeyrobot]

Helle for me. Jets are primed to take another step and should be able to with him. The Wings are going in the other direction

[havanablast21]

Hellebuyck for me as well. For the player as much as for the team he plays for.

[Axeman33]

Straight up I prefer Hellebuyck this deal sounds like it's more than straight up.

Post the full details of the trade and get opinions on that instead of only part of the deal.

- - - Updated - - -

Straight up I prefer Hellebuyck this deal sounds like it's more than straight up.

Post the full details of the trade and get opinions on that instead of only part of the deal.

[finminer]

The other pieces are in flux, as we've been going back and forth. His latest offer is Thornton & Kesler (this year only, but I could flip them), Gallagher 18-19 & Vesey 20-21 + Mrazek for Helly, Palat & JT Miller (this year & next), Subban 17-18. I can't take this deal because I would have more than the 10 max contracts. I also have 4 other prospects that will need contracts by mid 17-18, Rantanen, BRitchie, Aho & Matheson. Rakell is about the only other piece that would be worthwhile.

[chuckcouples]

I like Hellebuyck quite a bit more than Mrazek. He's a better goalie on a better team for the future. It's not that close.

[Wonko]

I prefer Hellebuyck for all the previous reasons cited.