Voracek & OEL for MacKinnon & Giordano

[Big Baby]

Who wins.
My league settings

[Hank n Dank]

Depends on what the salary of the Jake and OEL are.

I don't like Gio's $6.7m salary...

What do you mean by "no limit keeper" ... Does that mean you can keep as many or as few players as you want?

Anyways, this year I like Jake/OEL.
Long-term it's closer, but you've got lots of firepower up front and OEL gets a ton of points for a D, Gio is on the downswing I'd think points-wise

[Eskimo Brother]

I'll go MacK and Gio, but it is very close!

[stevegamer]

OEL/Voracek, by a slim margin.

[Sulla]

What does the extra/decreased salary do for you?

[Big Baby]

I take on a bit of money. But nothing I can't handle. Less than 1 million.

I know it's very close. Maybe in these cases it's best to keep what you have. I worry that if I trade MacKinnon he blows up.

[cujothespaz]

As much as I like MacKinnon, not sure if he'll reach full potential and what is ceiling will be. I think his floor is lower than Voracek's. I would do the trade and take Voracek/OEL, as OEL will (is already) be a real stud and Giordano is getting older and is more injury prone. Voracek is mroe proven than MacK. As everybody does, I think it is a slim margin and whatever you decide to do won't be a bad decision in my opinion.

[Bass56]

As much as I like MacKinnon, not sure if he'll reach full potential and what is ceiling will be. I think his floor is lower than Voracek's. I would do the trade and take Voracek/OEL, as OEL will (is already) be a real stud and Giordano is getting older and is more injury prone. Voracek is mroe proven than MacK. As everybody does, I think it is a slim margin and whatever you decide to do won't be a bad decision in my opinion.

I prefer the 2 proven guys in their peak over one that SHOULD reach his and another that COULD maintain his production although he is not getting younger.

[cujothespaz]

I prefer the 2 proven guys in their peak over one that SHOULD reach his and another that COULD maintain his production although he is not getting younger.

That's eaxactly what I thought, you summarized it better than I did haha